| Hint | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Home to koalas and kangaroos | Australia | 99%
|
| Prison island in San Francisco Bay | Alcatraz | 98%
|
| Shares its name with the secondmost populous city in the UAE | Abu Dhabi | 93%
|
| Barbuda's counterpart | Antigua | 90%
|
| The A of the ABC islands | Aruba | 89%
|
| Ancient island that fell into the sea | Atlantis | 84%
|
| Antarctica's largest island or the greatest Greek conqueror | Alexander | 77%
|
| Prison where Sirius Black was held | Azkaban | 59%
|
| Largest Welsh island | Anglesey | 45%
|
| Northernmost of the Leeward Islands | Anguilla | 42%
|
| Makes up a British Overseas Territorywith St. Helena and Tristan da Cunha | Ascension | 39%
|
| Northernmost of the inhabitedChannel Islands | Alderney | 31%
|
| French island roughly equidistant to the land masses of Madagascar, Australia, and Antarctica / Dutch capital | Amsterdam | 31%
|
| Island from "Jaws" | Amity Island | 26%
|
| Island where King Arthur's sword, Excalibur, was forged | Avalon | 24%
|
| Referred to as "Scotland in Miniature" | Arran | 23%
|
| Northernmost of the Greek Cyclades | Andros | 15%
|
| The most populous city of Indonesia's Maluku Islands is located on this one | Ambon | 12%
|
| The southeastern part of Copenhagenis built on this island | Amager | 9%
|
| Second-largest of the British Virgin Islands | Anegada | 3%
|