| Hint | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Mediterranean island nation | Malta | 99%
|
| Largest island in the Indian Ocean | Madagascar | 98%
|
| One of the five boroughs of NYC | Manhattan | 96%
|
| The two largest of the Balearic Islands | Mallorca | 90%
|
| Home of the Dodo | Mauritius | 90%
|
| The two largest of the Balearic Islands | Menorca | 83%
|
| Quebec's most populous island / city | Montreal | 80%
|
| French island in the Caribbean | Martinique | 76%
|
| Autonomous Portuguese island-region | Madeira | 70%
|
| Large southern Philippine island | Mindanao | 62%
|
| Capital of the Marshall Islands | Majuro | 56%
|
| British island in the Caribbean | Montserrat | 55%
|
| Tanzanian island / organized criminals | Mafia | 49%
|
| Home to Haleakala National Park | Maui | 47%
|
| French department in the Indian Ocean | Mayotte | 47%
|
| Venezuelan island / popular cocktail | Margarita | 43%
|
| The Kennedy family vacationed on this Massachusetts island | Martha's Vineyard | 42%
|
| Largest island in the sea between Asian and European Turkey | Marmara | 39%
|
| Fourth-largest Scottish island | Mull | 24%
|
| Largest island of Seychelles | Mahé | 12%
|