| Clue | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Ancestral home of the Corleone family | Sicily | 100%
|
| Where the Algherese dialect of the Catalan language is spoken | Sardinia | 91%
|
| Able was I, ere I saw it | Elba | 73%
|
| Party island off the coast of Naples | Capri | 64%
|
| Home to Italy's southernmost point | Lampedusa | 47%
|
| Home to a famous fictional Count | Monte Cristo | 43%
|
| Island near Venice known for glassblowing | Murano | 43%
|
| Namesake of a turnover food created by the Italian-Americans in Philadelphia | Stromboli | 37%
|
| The English word for a lava-erupting mountain derived from this Italian island | Vulcano | 36%
|
| Spa island also off the coast of Naples | Ischia | 32%
|
| Island in the Venetian Lagoon known for lace work and its colorful homes | Burano | 24%
|
| Name of a fishing island near the above or the largest island in the Gulf of Taranto(hint: named after the first Pope) | San Pietro | 23%
|
| Barrier island that hosts the Venice Film Festival annually | Lido | 22%
|
| The cruise ship Costa Concordia foundered off the coast of this island in 2012 | Giglio Island | 19%
|
| Home to a currently active agricultural penal colony in the Tuscan Archipelago | Gorgona | 7%
|