| Clue | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Two main islands of New Zealand | North | 91%
|
| Two main islands of New Zealand | South | 91%
|
| World's smallest island nation | Nauru | 87%
|
| Home to the Moai statues | Easter | 83%
|
| Honolulu's island | O'ahu | 82%
|
| Appropriately known as "The Big Island" | Hawai'i | 81%
|
| French Polynesia's biggest island | Tahiti | 81%
|
| Where the U.S. tested nuclear weapons from 1946–1958 | Bikini | 78%
|
| "Van Diemen's Land", formerly | Tasmania | 78%
|
| Island nation that is in free association with New Zealand | Niue | 62%
|
| Hagåtña is this territory's capital | Guam | 59%
|
| Solomon Island that was site of a bloody WWII battle | Guadalcanal | 57%
|
| World's highest island | New Guinea | 56%
|
| Overwhelmingly voted to become independent in 2019 | Bougainville | 55%
|
| Home to Haleakala National Park | Maui | 55%
|
| Vanuatu's main island / Brazilian state | Espiritu {Santo} | 54%
|
| Home to more than half of Fiji's land area and population | {Viti} Levu | 50%
|
| HMS Bounty rediscovered it in 1790 | Pitcairn | 47%
|
| Second largest island of PNG | New Britain | 42%
|
| World's largest coral atoll, visited by Captain Cook on 24 December 1777 | Kiritimati (Christmas) | 28%
|
| Main island of New Caledonia | Grande Terre | 18%
|
| World's largest sand island | Fraser | 10%
|