| Island | Country | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Alcatraz | United States of America | 97%
|
| Crete | Greece | 95%
|
| Honshu | Japan | 95%
|
| Isle of Man | United Kingdom | 95%
|
| Manhattan | United States of America | 95%
|
| Newfoundland | Canada | 92%
|
| Greenland | Denmark | 92%
|
| Bali | Indonesia | 92%
|
| Java | Indonesia | 92%
|
| Sicily | Italy | 92%
|
| Venice | Italy | 92%
|
| Borneo | Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia | 89%
|
| Vancouver Island | Canada | 89%
|
| Corsica | France | 89%
|
| Rhodes | Greece | 89%
|
| Sardinia | Italy | 89%
|
| Hispaniola | Dominican Republic, Haiti | 87%
|
| Timor | Indonesia, Timor Leste | 87%
|
| Mallorca | Spain | 87%
|
| Phuket | Thailand | 87%
|
| Bermuda | United Kingdom | 87%
|
| Prince Edward Island | Canada | 84%
|
| Guam | United States of America | 84%
|
| Baffin Island | Canada | 82%
|
| Easter Island | Chile | 82%
|
| North Island | New Zealand | 82%
|
| New Guinea | Indonesia, Papua New Guinea | 79%
|
| South Island | New Zealand | 79%
|
| Zanzibar | Tanzania | 79%
|
| Aruba | the Netherlands | 79%
|
| Curacao | the Netherlands | 76%
|
| Cebu | the Philippines | 74%
|
| Kodiak Island | United States of America | 74%
|
| Norfolk Island | Australia | 71%
|
| Zealand | Denmark | 68%
|
| Anguilla | United Kingdom | 68%
|
| Bonaire | the Netherlands | 66%
|
| Jeju | South Korea | 42%
|
| Socotra | Yemen | 37%
|
| Taboga | Panama | 16%
|