| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Leader | Dutch Van Der Linde | 100%
|
| Co-founder | Hosea Matthews | 98%
|
| Child | Jack Marston | 96%
|
| Attacked by wolves in Ambarino | John Marston | 96%
|
| Gets drunk with Arthur in Valentine | Lenny Summers | 95%
|
| John's wife | Abigail Roberts | 93%
|
| Gets arrested in Strawberry | Micah Bell | 93%
|
| Mexican Revolutionary | Javier Escuella | 91%
|
| Teaches Arthur to hunt | Charles Smith | 90%
|
| Camp Cook | Pearson | 90%
|
| Lazy | Uncle | 90%
|
| Seeks revenge for her murdered husband | Sadie Adler | 89%
|
| Young Irish theif | Sean Macguire | 87%
|
| Best in the gang | Arthur Morgan | 86%
|
| Boss of the camp | Susan Grimshaw | 86%
|
| Used to be in the U.S. Cavalry | Bill Williamson | 85%
|
| Loanshark | Leopold Strauss | 85%
|
| Dutch's Lover | Molly O'Shea | 85%
|
| Scam artist, trigger woman | Karen Jones | 84%
|
| Ex-O'Driscoll Boy | Kieran Duffy | 83%
|
| Another scam artist woman | Mary-Beth Gaskill | 83%
|
| Formerly part of the Foreman brothers gang | Tilly Jackson | 83%
|
| Conman who is in and out of the camp | Josiah Trelawny | 76%
|
| Ex-clergy | Reverend Swanson | 73%
|
| Brother of above, hanged by Pinkertons | Mac Callander | 66%
|
| Dies shortly after the Blackwater botched heist | Davey Callander | 61%
|
| Woman killed after Blackwater heist | Jenny Kirk | 61%
|
| Micah's other friend | Joe | 50%
|
| Micah's friend | Cleet | 48%
|