| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB | 5 | Jim Kelly | 100%
|
| QB | 4 | Josh Allen | 100%
|
| WR | 4 | Stefon Diggs | 100%
|
| WR | 7 | Andre Reed | 93%
|
| TE | 1 | Dawson Knox | 89%
|
| RB | 5 | Thurman Thomas | 89%
|
| RB | 6 | O.J. Simpson | 86%
|
| DE | 11 | Bruce Smith | 82%
|
| TE | 1 | Dalton Kincaid | 82%
|
| RB | 1 | Bobby Smith | 75%
|
| CB | 2 | Tre'Davious White | 75%
|
| QB | 1 | Tyrod Taylor | 75%
|
| RB | 3 | James Cook | 71%
|
| T | 5 | Dion Dawkins | 68%
|
| RB | 3 | LeSean McCoy | 64%
|
| QB | 1 | Drew Bledsoe | 61%
|
| LB | 1 | Matt Milano | 61%
|
| DT | 6 | Kyle Williams | 57%
|
| DE | 2 | Mario Williams | 54%
|
| DE | 1 | Ben Williams | 50%
|
| QB | 1 | Doug Flutie | 50%
|
| QB | 6 | Jack Kemp | 50%
|
| CB | 1 | Jordan Poyer | 50%
|
| CB | 1 | Micah Hyde | 50%
|
| G | 8 | Ruben Brown | 50%
|
| RB | 1 | Marshawn Lynch | 46%
|
| LB | 1 | Zach Brown | 46%
|
| RB | 1 | C.J. Spiller | 43%
|
| WR | 3 | Eric Moulds | 43%
|
| CB | 1 | Stephon Gilmore | 43%
|
| WR | 1 | Charley Ferguson | 39%
|
| K | 1 | Scott Norwood | 39%
|
| LB | 5 | Cornelius Bennett | 36%
|
| WR | 1 | James Lofton | 36%
|
| C | 1 | Mitch Morse | 36%
|
| WR | 7 | Steve Tasker | 32%
|
| LB | 2 | Tremaine Edmunds | 32%
|
| CB | 5 | Butch Byrd | 29%
|
| C | 1 | Connor McGovern | 29%
|
| CB | 3 | Jairus Byrd | 29%
|
| G | 5 | Joe DeLamielleure | 29%
|
| DT | 1 | Lorenzo Alexander | 29%
|
| RS | 2 | Andre Roberts | 25%
|
| LB | 3 | Bryce Paup | 25%
|
| LB | 2 | Darryl Talley | 25%
|
| C | 1 | Eric Wood | 25%
|
| RB | 1 | Travis Henry | 25%
|
| CB | 1 | Henry Jones | 21%
|
| G | 3 | Richie Incognito | 21%
|
| CB | 3 | Robert James | 21%
|
| LB | 2 | Takeo Spikes | 21%
|
| G | 8 | Billy Shaw | 18%
|
| P | 2 | Brian Moorman | 18%
|
| WR | 1 | Frank Lewis | 18%
|
| DT | 5 | Fred Smerlas | 18%
|
| C | 3 | Kent Hull | 18%
|
| DT | 2 | Marcell Dareus | 18%
|
| QB | 1 | Daryle Lamonica | 14%
|
| WR | 1 | Elbert Dubenion | 14%
|
| T | 2 | Jason Peters | 14%
|
| DT | 1 | Sam Adams | 14%
|
| LB | 3 | Shane Conlan | 14%
|
| DE | 2 | Aaron Schobel | 11%
|
| RB | 1 | Billy Joe | 11%
|
| FB | 3 | Cookie Gilchrist | 11%
|
| RB | 3 | Joe Cribbs | 11%
|
| FB | 1 | Larry Centers | 11%
|
| DT | 3 | Ted Washington | 11%
|
| CB | 1 | Billy Atkins | 7%
|
| RB | 1 | Greg Bell | 7%
|
| WR | 1 | Jerry Butler | 7%
|
| G | 2 | Jim Ritcher | 7%
|
| FB | 1 | Keith Lincoln | 7%
|
| T | 1 | Ken Rice | 7%
|
| CB | 1 | Nate Clements | 7%
|
| TE | 2 | Paul Costa | 7%
|
| CB | 1 | Terrence McGee | 7%
|
| CB | 1 | Tony Greene | 7%
|
| T | 1 | Will Wolford | 7%
|
| C | 1 | Al Bemiller | 4%
|
| LB | 2 | Archie Matsos | 4%
|
| RB | 1 | Bobby Burnett | 4%
|
| CB | 1 | Booker Edgerson | 4%
|
| T | 1 | Dave Foley | 4%
|
| QB | 1 | Ed Rutkowski | 4%
|
| TE | 4 | Ernie Warlick | 4%
|
| CB | 5 | George Saimes | 4%
|
| T | 1 | Harold Olson | 4%
|
| LB | 2 | Harry Jacobs | 4%
|
| WR | 1 | Haven Moses | 4%
|
| T | 2 | Howard Ballard | 4%
|
| WR | 1 | J.D. Hill | 4%
|
| DT | 4 | Jim Dunaway | 4%
|
| LB | 2 | John Tracey | 4%
|
| DE | 1 | LaVerne Torczon | 4%
|
| WR | 1 | Marlin Briscoe | 4%
|
| LB | 1 | Marty Schottenheimer | 4%
|
| C | 1 | Mike Schneck | 4%
|
| LB | 6 | Mike Stratton | 4%
|
| CB | 2 | Nate Odomes | 4%
|
| K | 1 | Pete Gogolak | 4%
|
| WR | 1 | Pete Mills | 4%
|
| G | 1 | Rodger Saffold | 4%
|
| DE | 2 | Ron McDole | 4%
|
| LB | 1 | Sam Cowart | 4%
|
| FB | 2 | Sam Gash | 4%
|
| T | 5 | Stew Barber | 4%
|
| CB | 2 | Tom Janik | 4%
|
| DT | 4 | Tom Sestak | 4%
|
| RB | 2 | Wray Carlton | 4%
|
| LB | 1 | Bill Laskey | 0%
|
| WR | 1 | Bo Roberson | 0%
|
| CB | 1 | Charley Warner | 0%
|
| DT | 1 | Chuck McMurty | 0%
|
| C | 1 | Dave Behrman | 0%
|
| T | 1 | Dick Hudson | 0%
|
| DT | 1 | Dudley Meredith | 0%
|
| G | 1 | George Flint | 0%
|
| CB | 1 | Hagood Clarke | 0%
|
| DT | 1 | Henry Schmidt | 0%
|
| G | 1 | Joe O'Donnell | 0%
|
| LB | 1 | Marv Matuszak | 0%
|
| K | 1 | Mike Mercer | 0%
|
| LB | 1 | Paul Maguire | 0%
|
| DE | 1 | Tom Day | 0%
|
| CB | 1 | Willie West | 0%
|