| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| WR | 5 | Ja'Marr Chase | 100%
|
| QB | 2 | Joe Burrow | 100%
|
| QB | 3 | Andy Dalton | 94%
|
| WR | 7 | A.J. Green | 92%
|
| QB | 2 | Carson Palmer | 89%
|
| WR | 6 | Chad Johnson | 89%
|
| QB | 4 | Ken Anderson | 89%
|
| T | 11 | Anthony Munoz | 86%
|
| RB | 1 | Joe Mixon | 86%
|
| WR | 1 | Tee Higgins | 86%
|
| T | 4 | Willie Anderson | 86%
|
| QB | 3 | Boomer Esiason | 81%
|
| RB | 1 | Harold Green | 81%
|
| RB | 1 | Rudi Johnson | 78%
|
| RB | 1 | Pete Johnson | 75%
|
| C | 1 | Bob Johnson | 72%
|
| WR | 1 | Eddie Brown | 69%
|
| DT | 7 | Geno Atkins | 69%
|
| DE | 4 | Trey Hendrickson | 67%
|
| RB | 3 | Corey Dillon | 61%
|
| QB | 1 | Joe Flacco | 61%
|
| CB | 1 | Adam Jones | 58%
|
| T | 3 | Andrew Whitworth | 56%
|
| DE | 2 | Carlos Dunlap | 53%
|
| TE | 1 | Tyler Eifert | 53%
|
| WR | 3 | Cris Collinsworth | 50%
|
| LB | 1 | Vontaze Burfict | 50%
|
| P | 1 | Kevin Huber | 44%
|
| QB | 1 | Jeff Blake | 39%
|
| WR | 2 | Carl Pickens | 36%
|
| FB | 1 | Lorenzo Neal | 36%
|
| WR | 1 | T.J. Houshmandzadeh | 36%
|
| RB | 4 | James Brooks | 33%
|
| TE | 2 | Jermaine Gresham | 33%
|
| CB | 1 | Reggie Nelson | 33%
|
| TE | 4 | Bob Trumpy | 31%
|
| WR | 4 | Isaac Curtis | 22%
|
| K | 1 | Shayne Graham | 22%
|
| DT | 2 | Tim Krumrie | 22%
|
| TE | 1 | Clark Harris | 19%
|
| CB | 1 | Eric Thomas | 19%
|
| CB | 1 | Deltha O'Neal | 17%
|
| CB | 6 | Lemar Parrish | 17%
|
| G | 3 | Max Montoya | 17%
|
| CB | 1 | Tory James | 17%
|
| RB | 2 | Paul Robinson | 14%
|
| CB | 3 | David Fulcher | 11%
|
| LB | 1 | Bill Bergey | 8%
|
| RB | 1 | Cedric Peerman | 8%
|
| TE | 1 | Dan Ross | 8%
|
| DT | 2 | Mike Reid | 8%
|
| TE | 3 | Rodney Holman | 8%
|
| CB | 3 | Tommy Casanova | 8%
|
| DE | 2 | Coy Bacon | 6%
|
| LB | 1 | Jim LeClair | 6%
|
| CB | 1 | Tremain Mack | 6%
|
| CB | 1 | Ashley Ambrose | 3%
|
| WR | 1 | Chip Myers | 3%
|
| WR | 1 | Pat McInally | 3%
|