| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3B | 6 | José Ramírez | 91%
|
| OF | 4 | Manny Ramírez | 90%
|
| 1B | 3 | Jim Thome | 74%
|
| P | 3 | Corey Kluber | 72%
|
| P | 8 | Bob Feller | 71%
|
| P | 2 | Shane Bieber | 69%
|
| SS | 4 | Francisco Lindor | 66%
|
| 1B | 1 | Carlos Santana | 65%
|
| P | 3 | Emmanuel Clase | 65%
|
| LF | 4 | Albert Belle | 63%
|
| 3B | 1 | Buddy Bell | 62%
|
| P | 3 | Gary Bell | 62%
|
| 2B | 3 | Roberto Alomar | 62%
|
| C | 6 | Sandy Alomar | 62%
|
| P | 1 | Trevor Bauer | 62%
|
| CF | 5 | Kenny Lofton | 54%
|
| SS | 3 | Omar Vizquel | 50%
|
| LF | 1 | Steven Kwan | 49%
|
| CF | 3 | Grady Sizemore | 47%
|
| P | 7 | Bob Lemon | 44%
|
| P | 3 | CC Sabathia | 44%
|
| DH | 1 | David Fry | 44%
|
| P | 1 | Dennis Martínez | 44%
|
| C | 3 | Victor Martinez | 44%
|
| 2B | 1 | Andrés Giménez | 43%
|
| OF | P | 1 | Al Smith | 40%
|
| P | 1 | Cliff Lee | 40%
|
| 2B | 2 | Jason Kipnis | 40%
|
| C | 1 | Yan Gomes | 40%
|
| P | 3 | Doug Jones | 38%
|
| 2B | 3 | Carlos Baerga | 37%
|
| P | 2 | Chris Pérez | 37%
|
| 1B | 1 | Josh Naylor | 37%
|
| P | 1 | Andrew Miller | 35%
|
| SS | 8 | Lou Boudreau | 32%
|
| CF | 7 | Larry Doby | 31%
|
| CF | 6 | Earl Averill | 29%
|
| P | 2 | Gaylord Perry | 28%
|
| P | 1 | Jim Perry | 28%
|
| OF | 3 | Michael Brantley | 26%
|
| P | 1 | Roberto Hernández | 26%
|
| P | 1 | Johnny Allen | 25%
|
| P | 2 | José Mesa | 25%
|
| 3B | 4 | Al Rosen | 24%
|
| P | 3 | Early Wynn | 24%
|
| OF | 1 | Juan González | 22%
|
| P | 1 | Bartolo Colon | 21%
|
| RF | 3 | Rocky Colavito | 21%
|
| P | 6 | Sam McDowell | 21%
|
| SS | 2 | Asdrúbal Cabrera | 19%
|
| P | 3 | Charles Nagy | 18%
|
| RF | 1 | David Justice | 18%
|
| C | 1 | Jim Hegan | 16%
|
| P | 1 | Justin Masterson | 16%
|
| P | 4 | Mel Harder | 16%
|
| P | 3 | Mike García | 16%
|
| 3B | 1 | Travis Fryman | 16%
|
| DH | 2 | Andre Thornton | 15%
|
| P | 1 | Len Barker | 15%
|
| P | 1 | Bert Blyleven | 13%
|
| P | 1 | Jake Westbrook | 13%
|
| 2B | 3 | Joe Gordon | 13%
|
| P | 1 | Bob Wickman | 12%
|
| P | 1 | Brad Hand | 12%
|
| 3B | 2 | Brook Jacoby | 12%
|
| P | 2 | Herb Score | 12%
|
| P | 1 | Luis Tiant | 12%
|
| C | 2 | Ray Fosse | 12%
|
| P | 1 | Rick Sutcliffe | 12%
|
| P | 1 | Dennis Eckersley | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Greg Swindell | 10%
|
| 3B | 1 | Toby Harrah | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Wes Ferrell | 10%
|
| 2B | 3 | Bobby Avila | 9%
|
| C | 1 | Bo Díaz | 9%
|
| C | 1 | Buddy Rosar | 9%
|
| LF | 1 | Dale Mitchell | 9%
|
| P | 1 | Ken Keltner | 9%
|
| 1B | 1 | Pat Tabler | 9%
|
| 2B | 1 | Manny Trillo | 7%
|
| P | 1 | Mudcat Grant | 7%
|
| RF | 1 | Vic Wertz | 7%
|
| P | 1 | Chuck Finley | 6%
|
| P | 1 | Danny Salazar | 6%
|
| OF | 1 | Matt Lawton | 6%
|
| 3B | 2 | Max Alvis | 6%
|
| 2B | 1 | Ray Mack | 6%
|
| C | 6 | John Romano | 4%
|
| P | 1 | Ken Schrom | 4%
|
| P | 1 | Steve Hargan | 4%
|
| OF | 2 | Tito Francona | 4%
|
| CF | 1 | Vic Davalillo | 4%
|
| P | 2 | Barry Latman | 3%
|
| P | 2 | Dave LaRoche | 3%
|
| P | 3 | Dick Donovan | 3%
|
| P | 1 | Don Mossi | 3%
|
| C | 2 | Frankie Hayes | 3%
|
| OF | 2 | George Hendrick | 3%
|
| P | 2 | Jim Bagby | 3%
|
| P | 2 | Jim Kern | 3%
|
| C | 1 | Joe Azcue | 3%
|
| 1B | 1 | Mickey Vernon | 3%
|
| LF | 3 | Minnie Miñoso | 3%
|
| 2B | 1 | Ronnie Belliard | 3%
|
| P | 1 | Sid Monge | 3%
|
| P | 1 | Sonny Siebert | 3%
|
| 1B | 6 | Vic Power | 3%
|
| P | 2 | Cal McLish | 1%
|
| OF | 3 | Harvey Kuenn | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Jack Kralick | 1%
|
| LF | 2 | Jeff Heath | 1%
|
| 2B | 3 | Johnny Temple | 1%
|
| P | 2 | Ray Narleski | 1%
|
| RF | 1 | Roy Cullenbine | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Steve Gromek | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Allie Reynolds | 0%
|
| P | 1 | Al Milnar | 0%
|
| P | 3 | Dick Stigman | 0%
|
| LF | 1 | Joe Vosmik | 0%
|
| 2B | 1 | Jorge Orta | 0%
|
| P | 1 | Oral Hildebrand | 0%
|
| OF | 1 | Oris Hockett | 0%
|
| C | 2 | Rollie Hemsley | 0%
|