| Category | # | Player | Amount | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hits | 1 | Ty Cobb | 3,900 | 97%
|
| Batting Average | 1 | Ty Cobb | .368 | 97%
|
| Runs | 1 | Ty Cobb | 2,086 | 97%
|
| Stolen Bases | 1 | Ty Cobb | 869 | 97%
|
| Home Runs | T2 | Miguel Cabrera | 373 | 96%
|
| Hits | 8 | Miguel Cabrera | 2,332 | 96%
|
| Runs | 9 | Miguel Cabrera | 1,102 | 96%
|
| Home Runs | 1 | Al Kaline | 399 | 92%
|
| Hits | 2 | Al Kaline | 3,007 | 92%
|
| Runs | 3 | Al Kaline | 1,622 | 92%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 2 | Justin Verlander | 2,373 | 89%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 7 | Justin Verlander | 183 | 89%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 3 | Jack Morris | 1,980 | 81%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 5 | Jack Morris | 198 | 81%
|
| Home Runs | 7 | Lou Whitaker | 244 | 80%
|
| Hits | 6 | Lou Whitaker | 2,369 | 80%
|
| Runs | 4 | Lou Whitaker | 1,386 | 80%
|
| Stolen Bases | 10 | Lou Whitaker | 143 | 80%
|
| Hits | 7 | Alan Trammell | 2,365 | 79%
|
| Runs | 6 | Alan Trammell | 1,231 | 79%
|
| Stolen Bases | 5 | Alan Trammell | 236 | 79%
|
| Home Runs | 4 | Hank Greenberg | 306 | 75%
|
| Batting Average | 8 | Hank Greenberg | .319 | 75%
|
| Home Runs | 6 | Cecil Fielder | 245 | 65%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 1 | Mickey Lolich | 2,679 | 64%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 3 | Mickey Lolich | 207 | 64%
|
| Home Runs | 9 | Lance Parrish | 212 | 60%
|
| Home Runs | T2 | Norm Cash | 373 | 60%
|
| Hits | 10 | Norm Cash | 1,793 | 60%
|
| Runs | 10 | Norm Cash | 1,027 | 60%
|
| Hits | 3 | Charlie Gehringer | 2,839 | 57%
|
| Batting Average | 7 | Charlie Gehringer | .320 | 57%
|
| Runs | 2 | Charlie Gehringer | 1,775 | 57%
|
| Stolen Bases | 9 | Charlie Gehringer | 181 | 57%
|
| Stolen Bases | 6 | Kirk Gibson | 194 | 57%
|
| Saves | 1 | Todd Jones | 235 | 57%
|
| Saves | 4 | Willie Hernandez | 120 | 57%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 4 | Hal Newhouser | 1,770 | 55%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 4 | Hal Newhouser | 200 | 55%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 10 | Denny McLain | 1,150 | 52%
|
| Home Runs | 5 | Willie Horton | 262 | 49%
|
| Hits | 4 | Harry Heilmann | 2,499 | 43%
|
| Batting Average | 2 | Harry Heilmann | .342 | 43%
|
| Runs | 7 | Harry Heilmann | 1,209 | 43%
|
| Home Runs | 10 | Bill Freehan | 200 | 41%
|
| Stolen Bases | 4 | Ron LeFlore | 294 | 40%
|
| Hits | 5 | Sam Crawford | 2,466 | 39%
|
| Runs | 8 | Sam Crawford | 1,115 | 39%
|
| Stolen Bases | 3 | Sam Crawford | 318 | 39%
|
| Saves | 10 | Francisco Rodríguez | 51 | 37%
|
| Batting Average | 5 | George Kell | .325 | 29%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 6 | Jim Bunning | 1,406 | 29%
|
| Saves | 2 | Mike Henneman | 154 | 29%
|
| Saves | 3 | John Hiller | 125 | 28%
|
| Saves | 5 | Jose Valverde | 119 | 28%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 9 | Dizzy Trout | 1,199 | 24%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 8 | Dizzy Trout | 161 | 24%
|
| Saves | 6 | Aurelio Lopez | 85 | 23%
|
| Home Runs | 8 | Rudy York | 239 | 21%
|
| Saves | 8 | Shane Greene | 65 | 21%
|
| Batting Average | 6 | Heinie Manush | .321 | 19%
|
| Hits | 9 | Bobby Veach | 1,859 | 17%
|
| Stolen Bases | 8 | Bobby Veach | 189 | 17%
|
| Saves | 7 | Fernando Rodney | 70 | 16%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 7 | George Mullin | 1,380 | 16%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 2 | George Mullin | 209 | 16%
|
| Batting Average | 10 | Harvey Kuenn | .314 | 16%
|
| Batting Average | 4 | Dale Alexander | .331 | 15%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 8 | Hooks Dauss | 1,201 | 15%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 1 | Hooks Dauss | 223 | 15%
|
| Runs | 5 | Donie Bush | 1,242 | 13%
|
| Stolen Bases | 2 | Donie Bush | 402 | 13%
|
| Strikeouts (Pitching) | 5 | Tommy Bridges | 1,674 | 11%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 6 | Tommy Bridges | 194 | 11%
|
| Saves | 9 | Terry Fox | 55 | 9%
|
| Batting Average | 9 | Gee Walker | .317 | 8%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 9 | Bill Donovan | 140 | 5%
|
| Batting Average | 3 | Bob Fothergill | .337 | 4%
|
| Wins (Pitching) | 10 | Earl Whitehill | 133 | 4%
|
| Stolen Bases | 7 | George Moriarty | 193 | 4%
|