| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3B | 13 | George Brett | 95%
|
| C | 9 | Salvador Pérez | 94%
|
| P | 2 | Bret Saberhagen | 79%
|
| SS | 1 | Bobby Witt Jr. | 77%
|
| LF | 3 | Alex Gordon | 74%
|
| 1B | 1 | Eric Hosmer | 68%
|
| 3B | 2 | Mike Moustakas | 67%
|
| CF | 1 | Lorenzo Cain | 65%
|
| P | 1 | Zack Greinke | 65%
|
| 2B | 5 | Frank White | 64%
|
| SS | 1 | Alcides Escobar | 59%
|
| P | 2 | Wade Davis | 53%
|
| P | 3 | Dan Quisenberry | 52%
|
| OF | 2 | Willie Wilson | 52%
|
| LF | 1 | Bo Jackson | 50%
|
| CF | 5 | Amos Otis | 48%
|
| DH | 1 | Billy Butler | 45%
|
| P | 1 | Seth Lugo | 42%
|
| DH | 5 | Mike Sweeney | 41%
|
| 2B | 2 | Whit Merrifield | 41%
|
| P | 2 | Greg Holland | 39%
|
| DH | 2 | Hal McRae | 38%
|
| P | 1 | Kevin Appier | 38%
|
| 1B | 2 | John Mayberry | 36%
|
| P | 1 | Cole Ragans | 33%
|
| C | 3 | Darrell Porter | 32%
|
| SS | 1 | Freddie Patek | 27%
|
| P | 2 | Kelvin Herrera | 27%
|
| P | 2 | Mark Gubicza | 26%
|
| RF | 1 | Danny Tartabull | 23%
|
| RF | 1 | Jermaine Dye | 23%
|
| P | 1 | Larry Gura | 23%
|
| 2B | 4 | Cookie Rojas | 21%
|
| P | 1 | David Cone | 21%
|
| P | 3 | Jeff Montgomery | 21%
|
| P | 2 | Joakim Soria | 18%
|
| OF | 1 | Andrew Benintendi | 17%
|
| P | 2 | Steve Busby | 17%
|
| P | 1 | Jason Vargas | 15%
|
| 3B | 1 | Kevin Seitzer | 14%
|
| P | 1 | Aaron Crow | 11%
|
| C | 1 | Ellie Rodríguez | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Gil Meche | 11%
|
| 3B | 1 | Dean Palmer | 9%
|
| P | 2 | Jose Rosado | 9%
|
| 1B | 1 | Ken Harvey | 9%
|
| SS | 1 | Kurt Stillwell | 9%
|
| LF | 1 | Lou Piniella | 8%
|
| P | 1 | Mark Redman | 8%
|
| P | 1 | Mike MacDougal | 8%
|
| RF | 1 | Richie Scheinblum | 8%
|