| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB | 9 | Dan Marino | 100%
|
| QB | 1 | Tua Tagovailoa | 96%
|
| QB | 8 | Bob Griese | 91%
|
| RB | 1 | De'Von Achane | 91%
|
| WR | 2 | Tyreek Hill | 91%
|
| DE | 6 | Jason Taylor | 83%
|
| TE | 1 | Jonnu Smith | 78%
|
| WR | 5 | Mark Clayton | 78%
|
| LB | 7 | Zach Thomas | 78%
|
| RB | 5 | Larry Csonka | 74%
|
| RB | 1 | Ricky Williams | 74%
|
| RB | 1 | Raheem Mostert | 70%
|
| CB | 4 | Xavien Howard | 70%
|
| RB | 1 | Delvin Williams | 65%
|
| CB | 1 | Jalen Ramsey | 65%
|
| CB | 2 | Rashad Jones | 61%
|
| LB | 5 | Cameron Wake | 57%
|
| RB | 1 | Jay Ajayi | 57%
|
| C | 5 | Dwight Stephenson | 52%
|
| RB | 3 | Mercury Morris | 52%
|
| DT | 1 | Ndamukong Suh | 52%
|
| FB | 1 | Alec Ingold | 48%
|
| WR | 3 | Jarvis Landry | 48%
|
| RB | 1 | Ronnie Brown | 48%
|
| RB | 2 | Jim Kiick | 43%
|
| WR | 5 | Paul Warfield | 43%
|
| T | 2 | Terron Armstead | 43%
|
| CB | 3 | Dick Anderson | 39%
|
| TE | 1 | Keith Jackson | 39%
|
| G | 5 | Larry Little | 39%
|
| T | 4 | Jake Long | 35%
|
| C | 6 | Jim Langer | 35%
|
| CB | 5 | Jake Scott | 30%
|
| LB | 3 | Nick Buoniconti | 30%
|
| P | 2 | Reggie Roby | 30%
|
| LB | 1 | A.J. Duhe | 26%
|
| CB | 3 | Brent Grimes | 26%
|
| K | 2 | Garo Yepremian | 26%
|
| C | 3 | Mike Pouncey | 26%
|
| CB | 3 | Patrick Surtain | 26%
|
| G | 1 | Richie Incognito | 26%
|
| WR | 1 | Brandon Marshall | 22%
|
| WR | 2 | Irving Fryar | 22%
|
| WR | 1 | Nat Moore | 22%
|
| T | 1 | Wayne Moore | 22%
|
| G | 6 | Bob Kuechenberg | 17%
|
| WR | 1 | Chris Chambers | 17%
|
| G | 3 | Keith Sims | 17%
|
| T | 7 | Richmond Webb | 17%
|
| CB | 4 | Sam Madison | 17%
|
| DE | 1 | Bill Stanfill | 13%
|
| LB | 3 | Bryan Cox | 13%
|
| LB | 5 | John Offerdahl | 13%
|
| RB | 1 | Keith Byars | 13%
|
| T | 2 | Norm Evans | 13%
|
| K | 1 | Olindo Mare | 13%
|
| G | 2 | Roy Foster | 13%
|
| DE | 1 | Trace Armstrong | 13%
|
| CB | 1 | Yeremiah Bell | 13%
|
| DT | 5 | Bob Baumhower | 9%
|
| P | 1 | Brandon Fields | 9%
|
| CB | 3 | Brock Marion | 9%
|
| G | 4 | Ed Newman | 9%
|
| LB | 1 | Joey Porter | 9%
|
| DE | 1 | Kim Bokamper | 9%
|
| DT | 1 | Paul Soliai | 9%
|
| DT | 2 | Randy Starks | 9%
|
| DT | 2 | Tim Bowens | 9%
|
| C | 1 | Tim Ruddy | 9%
|
| DE | 1 | Adewale Ogunleye | 4%
|
| RB | 1 | Andra Franklin | 4%
|
| G | 1 | Branden Albert | 4%
|
| DT | 1 | Brian Sochia | 4%
|
| K | 1 | Dan Carpenter | 4%
|
| DE | 1 | Doug Betters | 4%
|
| DE | 1 | Ed Cooke | 4%
|
| TE | 2 | Ferrell Edmunds | 4%
|
| DE | 1 | Jeff Cross | 4%
|
| LB | 1 | Larry Izzo | 4%
|
| CB | 1 | Dick Westmoreland | 0%
|
| WR | 1 | Jack Clancy | 0%
|
| CB | 1 | Jimmy Warren | 0%
|
| LB | 1 | John Bramlett | 0%
|
| DE | 2 | John Denney | 0%
|
| WR | 1 | Karl Noonan | 0%
|
| CB | 1 | Tim Foley | 0%
|
| LB | 1 | Tom Erlandson | 0%
|
| C | 1 | Tom Goode | 0%
|
| CB | 1 | Willie West | 0%
|