| # | Player | Points | High School & Last Year | Current Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jay Smith | 2,841 | Mio - 1979 | Michigan Wolverines - (Director of Player Personnel & Development) | 56%
|
| 42 | Magic Johnson | 2,012 | Everett - 1977 | Retired in 2000 | 56%
|
| 31 | Marcus Johnson | 2,076 | Iron Mountain - 2020 | Free Agent | 56%
|
| 33 | Dustin Jones | 2,071 | North Branch Wesleyan - 1995 | Retired | 44%
|
| 2 | Mark Brown | 2,789 | Hastings - 1985 | Retired | 33%
|
| 29 | Mike Brown | 2,101 | Hastings - 1988 | Retired | 33%
|
| 14 | Richie Jordan | 2,210 | Fennville - 1965 | Retired in 1968 | 33%
|
| 7 | Drew Neitzel | 2,462 | Wyoming Park - 2004 | Retired in 2013 | 22%
|
| T21 | Brad Redford | 2,146 | Frankenmuth - 2008 | Retired in 2013 | 11%
|
| T21 | Charlie Bell | 2,146 | Southwestern Classical - 1997 | Retired in 2012 | 11%
|
| 4 | Chris Hass | 2,522 | Pellston - 2012 | Retired in 2017 | 11%
|
| 12 | Dane Fife | 2,287 | Clarkston - 1998 | Retired in 2002 | 11%
|
| 34 | Demetrius Lake | 2,069 | Holland - 2017 | Shoreline Wolves (PBL) | 11%
|
| 41 | Dugan Fife | 2,032 | Clarkston - 1992 | Retired in 1996 | 11%
|
| 32 | Dustin Orns | 2,073 | Tekonsha - 2008 | Retired | 11%
|
| 3 | Dylan Jergens | 2,782 | Howardsville Christian - 2019 | Central Michigan Chippewas | 11%
|
| 13 | Foster Wonders | 2,286 | Iron Mountain - 2021 | Southern Illinois Salukis | 11%
|
| 9 | Marcus Taylor | 2,448 | Waverly - 2000 | Retired in 2010 | 11%
|
| 6 | Mark Macon | 2,490 | Buena Vista - 1987 | Temple Owls - (Assistant to the Head Coach) | 11%
|
| 5 | Tory Jackson | 2,518 | Buena Vista - 2006 | Retired in 2012 | 11%
|
| 15 | Antoine Joubert | 2,208 | Southwestern - 1983 | Oakland CC Raiders - (Head Coach) | 0%
|
| 30 | Bob Gale | 2,086 | Trout Creek - 1966 | Retired in 1970 | 0%
|
| T37 | Brandon Dingman | 2,060 | Marcelona - 2015 | Retired in 2017 | 0%
|
| 24 | Dom Jacobetti | 2,140 | Negaunee St. Paul - 1965 | Retired | 0%
|
| 27 | Don Reid | 2,121 | St. Mary (Flint) - 1966 | Retired | 0%
|
| 20 | Gage Kreski | 2,178 | St. Ignace - 2016 | New York Giants (Rookie Minicamp) - NFL | 0%
|
| 36 | Jason Whitens | 2,062 | North Central (Powers) - 2017 | Michigan State Spartans | 0%
|
| 28 | Jeff Warren | 2,105 | Litchfield - 1989 | Died in 2016 | 0%
|
| 43 | Jim Hammerberg | 2,010 | Baraga - 1996 | Retired | 0%
|
| 25 | Jim Manning | 2,137 | Trout Creek - 1961 | Died in 2020 | 0%
|
| 17 | Joey Liedel | 2,202 | Mason - 2020 | Lake Superior State Lakers | 0%
|
| 39 | John Flynn | 2,045 | Petoskey - 1998 | Harbor Springs High School Rams - (Head Coach) | 0%
|
| 10 | Marcus Matelski | 2,421 | Boyne Falls - 2016 | Retired in 2020 | 0%
|
| T37 | Mark Gerber | 2,060 | Alanson - 1987 | Retired | 0%
|
| 8 | Matt Stuck | 2,449 | Manton - 1992 | Retired | 0%
|
| 40 | Nathan Chatfield | 2,044 | Northern Michigan Christian - 2005 | Retired | 0%
|
| 23 | Rick Baillergeon | 2,144 | Glen Lake - 1977 | Retired | 0%
|
| 19 | Ryan Hiller | 2,183 | Manton - 1998 | Retired | 0%
|
| 18 | Ryan Ross | 2,192 | Michigan Lutheran - 2008 | Retired | 0%
|
| 11 | Sander Scott | 2,358 | Northport - 1989 | Retired in 1992 | 0%
|
| 35 | Scott Spaanstra | 2,067 | Byron Center - 1988 | Retired | 0%
|
| 44 | Spencer Krannitz | 2,008 | North Muskegon - 2012 | Retired in 2017 | 0%
|
| 16 | Zach Goodline | 2,204 | Coloma - 2019 | Huntington University Foresters | 0%
|
| 26 | Zach Ingles | 2,130 | Greenville - 2002 | Belding High School Black Knights - (Head Coach) | 0%
|
| 45 | Zane Gay | 2,004 | Olivet - 2005 | Retired in 2009 | 0%
|