| # | Pitcher | CGs | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Walter Johnson | 531 | 94%
|
| 1 | Cy Young | 749 | 93%
|
| T73 | Bob Gibson | 255 | 70%
|
| 14 | Christy Mathewson | 435 | 70%
|
| T100 | Tom Seaver | 231 | 65%
|
| 75 | Steve Carlton | 254 | 61%
|
| 21 | Warren Spahn | 382 | 61%
|
| T6 | Bobby Mathews | 525 | 59%
|
| 13 | Pete Alexander | 436 | 58%
|
| T52 | Bob Feller | 279 | 57%
|
| T42 | Lefty Grove | 298 | 56%
|
| T85 | Phil Niekro | 245 | 50%
|
| T60 | Mordecai Brown | 271 | 48%
|
| 39 | Gaylord Perry | 303 | 47%
|
| 63 | Fergie Jenkins | 267 | 43%
|
| T79 | Sad Sam Jones | 250 | 43%
|
| T88 | Juan Marichal | 244 | 40%
|
| 38 | Robin Roberts | 305 | 38%
|
| 16 | Eddie Plank | 410 | 36%
|
| T69 | Carl Hubbell | 260 | 35%
|
| 29 | Red Ruffing | 335 | 35%
|
| 4 | Kid Nichols | 532 | 34%
|
| 2 | Pud Galvin | 646 | 32%
|
| 68 | Rube Waddell | 261 | 32%
|
| T49 | Early Wynn | 289 | 30%
|
| 3 | Tim Keefe | 552 | 30%
|
| 8 | Old Hoss Radbourn | 488 | 28%
|
| 67 | Doc White | 267 | 26%
|
| T79 | Ed Walsh | 250 | 26%
|
| 17 | Will White | 394 | 26%
|
| T44 | Ed Morris | 297 | 24%
|
| 9 | John Clarkson | 485 | 24%
|
| T6 | Mickey Welch | 525 | 23%
|
| 96 | Addie Joss | 234 | 21%
|
| T73 | Charles Bender | 255 | 21%
|
| 24 | Ted Lyons | 356 | 21%
|
| T33 | Burleigh Grimes | 314 | 20%
|
| T69 | Jack Chesbro | 260 | 20%
|
| T81 | Eddie Cicotte | 249 | 19%
|
| T81 | Herb Pennock | 249 | 19%
|
| 48 | Eppa Rixey | 290 | 18%
|
| 59 | Red Faber | 273 | 17%
|
| 19 | Vic Willis | 388 | 16%
|
| 18 | Amos Rusie | 393 | 14%
|
| T52 | Jack Taylor | 279 | 14%
|
| T33 | Joe McGinnity | 314 | 14%
|
| T52 | Wilbur Cooper | 279 | 12%
|
| T85 | John Ward | 245 | 10%
|
| T52 | Al Spalding | 279 | 9%
|
| T91 | Bucky Walters | 242 | 9%
|
| T100 | Carl Mays | 231 | 9%
|
| 11 | Jim McCormick | 466 | 9%
|
| 30 | Silver King | 328 | 9%
|
| 23 | Adonis Terry | 367 | 8%
|
| 84 | Bobo Newsom | 246 | 8%
|
| 25 | George Mullin | 353 | 8%
|
| 20 | Tommy Bond | 386 | 8%
|
| T85 | Hooks Dauss | 245 | 7%
|
| 47 | Brickyard Kennedy | 294 | 6%
|
| T91 | Deacon Phillippe | 242 | 6%
|
| 15 | Jack Powell | 422 | 6%
|
| 90 | Jack Quinn | 243 | 6%
|
| T49 | Bill Donovan | 289 | 5%
|
| T42 | Bob Caruthers | 298 | 5%
|
| 28 | Clark Griffith | 337 | 5%
|
| T98 | George Uhle | 232 | 5%
|
| 78 | Paul Derringer | 251 | 5%
|
| 10 | Tony Mullane | 468 | 5%
|
| 31 | Al Orth | 324 | 4%
|
| T64 | Jesse Tannehill | 264 | 4%
|
| T64 | Matt Kilroy | 264 | 4%
|
| 37 | Bill Dinneen | 306 | 3%
|
| 32 | Bill Hutchison | 321 | 3%
|
| 97 | Candy Cummings | 233 | 3%
|
| 26 | Charlie Buffinton | 351 | 3%
|
| 12 | Gus Weyhing | 449 | 3%
|
| T35 | Guy Hecker | 312 | 3%
|
| 22 | Jim Whitney | 377 | 3%
|
| 72 | Larry Corcoran | 256 | 3%
|
| 46 | Mark Baldwin | 295 | 3%
|
| 94 | Sam Leever | 241 | 3%
|
| 40 | George Bradley | 302 | 2%
|
| T64 | Ice Box Chamberlain | 264 | 2%
|
| 57 | Jack Stivetts | 278 | 2%
|
| 95 | Kid Gleason | 240 | 2%
|
| 41 | Theodore Breitenstein | 301 | 2%
|
| 51 | Bert Cunningham | 287 | 1%
|
| T88 | Harry Howell | 244 | 1%
|
| T44 | Pink Hawley | 297 | 1%
|
| 58 | Pretzels Getzien | 277 | 1%
|
| T35 | Red Donahue | 312 | 1%
|
| T52 | Sadie McMahon | 279 | 1%
|
| T91 | Bert Blyeven | 242 | 0%
|
| 27 | Chick Fraser | 342 | 0%
|
| T60 | Frank Dwyer | 271 | 0%
|
| T76 | Frank Killen | 253 | 0%
|
| T98 | Harry Staley | 232 | 0%
|
| 62 | Jouett Meekin | 270 | 0%
|
| T69 | Red Ehret | 260 | 0%
|
| T81 | Stump Weidman | 249 | 0%
|
| T76 | Win Mercer | 253 | 0%
|