| Position | Player | Draft Year | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| C | Greg Oden | 2007 | 77%
|
| SG | D'Angelo Russell | 2015 | 64%
|
| PG | Mike Conley | 2007 | 59%
|
| PF | E.J. Liddell | 2022 | 54%
|
| GF | Evan Turner | 2010 | 46%
|
| GF | Malaki Branham | 2022 | 46%
|
| C | Jared Sullinger | 2012 | 44%
|
| SG | Jim Jackson | 1992 | 41%
|
| SF | Keita Bates-Diop | 2018 | 41%
|
| SF | Wardell Jackson | 1974 | 41%
|
| C | Herb Williams | 1981 | 38%
|
| C | Ken Johnson | 2001 | 38%
|
| F | Clinton Smith | 1986 | 36%
|
| FC | Jerry Lucas | 1962 | 36%
|
| PF | Jim Smith | 1981 | 36%
|
| SF | Brice Sensabaugh | 2023 | 33%
|
| F | Jae'Sean Tate | 2018 | 33%
|
| GF | John Havlicek | 1962 | 33%
|
| G | Daequan Cook | 2007 | 28%
|
| F | Clark Kellogg | 1982 | 26%
|
| GF | Dennis Hopson | 1987 | 26%
|
| G | Duane Washington Jr. | 2021 | 26%
|
| PF | Lawrence Funderburke | 1994 | 26%
|
| G | Mark Baker | 1992 | 26%
|
| GF | Tony Campbell | 1984 | 26%
|
| PF | Bill Hosket | 1968 | 23%
|
| PF | Dave Sorenson | 1970 | 23%
|
| C | Gary Bradds | 1964 | 23%
|
| G | Larry Siegfried | 1961 | 23%
|
| C | Luke Witte | 1973 | 23%
|
| G | Michael Redd | 2000 | 23%
|
| G | Paul Huston | 1947 | 23%
|
| F | Chris Jent | 1992 | 21%
|
| PG | D.J. Carton | 2021 | 21%
|
| C | Granville Waiters | 1983 | 21%
|
| G | Kelvin Ransey | 1980 | 21%
|
| C | Kosta Koufos | 2008 | 21%
|
| SF | Mark Minor | 1972 | 21%
|
| G | Mel Nowell | 1962 | 21%
|
| PF | Mike Schnittker | 1950 | 21%
|
| G | Bob Donham | 1950 | 18%
|
| C | Byron Mullens | 2009 | 18%
|
| G | Derek Anderson | 1997 | 18%
|
| SG | Jordan Sibert | 2015 | 18%
|
| C | Micah Potter | 2021 | 18%
|
| FC | Brad Sellers | 1986 | 15%
|
| SG | Jim Cleamons | 1971 | 15%
|
| F | Joe Roberts | 1960 | 15%
|
| GF | Don Grate | 1947 | 13%
|
| FC | Othello Hunter | 2008 | 13%
|
| SF | Jamison Battle | 2024 | 10%
|
| C | Neil Johnston | 1948 | 10%
|
| C | Arnie Risen | N/A | 8%
|