| Position | Player | Selections | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB | Joe Namath | 5 | 92%
|
| RB | Curtis Martin | 3 | 70%
|
| CB | Darrelle Revis | 5 | 69%
|
| CB | Sauce Gardner | 2 | 69%
|
| DT | Quinnen Williams | 3 | 67%
|
| DT | Leonard Williams | 1 | 65%
|
| LB | Jermaine Johnson II | 1 | 64%
|
| WR | Keyshawn Johnson | 2 | 62%
|
| RB | Curley Johnson | 1 | 61%
|
| WR | Brandon Marshall | 1 | 56%
|
| C | Nick Mangold | 7 | 51%
|
| QB | Vinny Testaverde | 1 | 49%
|
| QB | Brett Favre | 1 | 45%
|
| LB | C.J. Mosley | 1 | 42%
|
| QB | Ken O'Brien | 2 | 40%
|
| RB | Thomas Jones | 1 | 39%
|
| DT | Joe Klecko | 4 | 38%
|
| DE | Mark Gastineau | 5 | 35%
|
| T | D'Brickashaw Ferguson | 3 | 34%
|
| RB | Chris Ivory | 1 | 31%
|
| CB | Jamal Adams | 2 | 31%
|
| C | Kevin Mawae | 6 | 31%
|
| DT | Sheldon Richardson | 1 | 30%
|
| WR | Al Toon | 3 | 27%
|
| CB | Antonio Cromartie | 2 | 27%
|
| DT | Muhammad Wilkerson | 1 | 27%
|
| QB | Boomer Esiason | 1 | 22%
|
| RB | Freeman McNeil | 3 | 21%
|
| LB | Mo Lewis | 2 | 21%
|
| WR | Wesley Walker | 2 | 20%
|
| FB | Richie Anderson | 1 | 19%
|
| T | Marvin Powell | 5 | 17%
|
| DE | John Abraham | 3 | 16%
|
| RB | Matt Snell | 3 | 16%
|
| G | Brandon Moore | 1 | 14%
|
| RB | Emerson Boozer | 2 | 13%
|
| LB | Jonathan Vilma | 1 | 13%
|
| WR | Rob Moore | 1 | 13%
|
| CB | Ty Law | 1 | 13%
|
| K | Jason Myers | 1 | 12%
|
| RB | Leon Washington | 1 | 12%
|
| CB | Aaron Glenn | 2 | 11%
|
| G | Alan Faneca | 2 | 11%
|
| RB | John Riggins | 1 | 11%
|
| DE | Shaun Ellis | 2 | 11%
|
| TE | Mickey Shuler | 2 | 10%
|
| WR | Andre Roberts | 1 | 9%
|
| DE | Don Maynard | 4 | 8%
|
| WR | George Sauer | 4 | 8%
|
| CB | Justin Miller | 1 | 8%
|
| QB | Al Dorow | 1 | 6%
|
| DE | Gerry Philbin | 2 | 6%
|
| C | Joe Fields | 2 | 6%
|
| DT | John Elliott | 3 | 6%
|
| LB | Lance Mehl | 1 | 6%
|
| LB | Larry Grantham | 5 | 6%
|
| WR | Bake Turner | 1 | 5%
|
| FB | Bill Mathis | 2 | 5%
|
| TE | Jerome Barkum | 1 | 5%
|
| T | Winston Hill | 8 | 5%
|
| LB | Al Atkinson | 1 | 4%
|
| G | Dave Herman | 2 | 4%
|
| CB | Justin Hardee | 1 | 4%
|
| CB | LaRon Landry | 1 | 4%
|
| TE | Rich Caster | 3 | 4%
|
| QB | Tom Tupa | 1 | 4%
|
| CB | Erik McMillan | 2 | 3%
|
| DT | Kris Jenkins | 1 | 3%
|
| T | Sherman Plunkett | 2 | 3%
|
| DE | Verlon Biggs | 3 | 3%
|
| G | Bob Mischak | 2 | 2%
|
| CB | Dainard Paulson | 2 | 2%
|
| CB | Dick Felt | 1 | 2%
|
| TE | Pete Lammons | 1 | 2%
|