| # | Player | Points | High School & Last Year | Current Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | LeBron James | 2,646 | St. Vincent-St. Mary - 2003 | Los Angeles Lakers | 95%
|
| 1 | Jon Diebler | 3,208 | Fostoria / Upper Sandusky - 2007 | Butler Bulldogs - (Assistant Coach) | 30%
|
| 2 | Luke Kennard | 2,977 | Franklin - 2015 | Los Angeles Clippers | 30%
|
| 12 | Bob Huggins | 2,438 | Conotton Valley Union / Indian Valley - 1971 | West Virginia Mountaineers - (Head Coach) | 20%
|
| 13 | Dante Jackson | 2,423 | McClain - 2007 | Xavier Musketeers - (Assistant Coach) | 20%
|
| 21 | Jim Jackson | 2,328 | Macomber - 1989 | Retired in 2006 | 15%
|
| 18 | Greg Simpson | 2,346 | Lima Senior - 1992 | Jailed | 10%
|
| 15 | Jarron Cumberland | 2,408 | Wilmington - 2016 | Delaware Blue Coats | 10%
|
| 11 | Jerry Lucas | 2,460 | Middletown - 1958 | Retired in 1974 | 10%
|
| 4 | Geno Ford | 2,680 | Cambridge - 2003 | Stony Brook Seawolves - (Head Coach) | 5%
|
| 14 | Jamar Butler | 2,412 | Shawnee - 2004 | Retired in 2012 | 5%
|
| 3 | Jay Burson | 2,958 | John Glenn - 1985 | Retired in 1991 | 5%
|
| 9 | Nate Davis | 2,562 | Bellaire - 2006 | Retired in 2012 | 5%
|
| 16 | Allan Hornyak | 2,385 | St. John Central - 1969 | Retired in 1973 | 0%
|
| 8 | Bill Szabo | 2,567 | Firelands - 1980 | Retired in 1982 | 0%
|
| 20 | Dan Monteroso | 2,340 | St. Clairsville - 2013 | Römerstrom Gladiators Trier - Germany | 0%
|
| 23 | Gary Kesler | 2,215 | Willshire - 1956 | Retired | 0%
|
| 19 | Glen Hursey | 2,341 | Glenford - 1948 | Died in 2020 | 0%
|
| 22 | Jerry Legge | 2,234 | West Lafayette - 1955 | Retired | 0%
|
| 10 | Larry Huston | 2,492 | Savannah - 1955 | Retired in 1959 | 0%
|
| 17 | Matt Witt | 2,366 | Bethel - 2002 | Retired in 2012 | 0%
|
| 24 | Mike Cross | 2,202 | Franklin Monroe - 1974 | Retired in 1977 | 0%
|
| 7 | Mike Phillips | 2,573 | Manchester - 1974 | Retired in 1990 | 0%
|
| 6 | Rex Leach | 2,581 | Mathews - 1955 | Died in 2021 | 0%
|