| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| RF | 18 | Roberto Clemente | 96%
|
| LF | 7 | Willie Stargell | 87%
|
| P | 1 | Paul Skenes | 83%
|
| CF | 5 | Andrew McCutchen | 82%
|
| RF | 4 | Dave Parker | 69%
|
| LF | 2 | Barry Bonds | 66%
|
| 2B | 9 | Bill Mazeroski | 66%
|
| P | 1 | Gerrit Cole | 61%
|
| 1B | 1 | Josh Bell | 55%
|
| SS | 1 | Jay Bell | 52%
|
| OF | 2 | Bryan Reynolds | 51%
|
| LF | 2 | Jason Bay | 48%
|
| LF | 5 | Ralph Kiner | 48%
|
| 3B | 4 | Bobby Bonilla | 45%
|
| C | 3 | Jason Kendall | 45%
|
| CF | 1 | Lloyd Waner | 44%
|
| RF | 3 | Paul Waner | 44%
|
| P | 2 | David Bednar | 41%
|
| SS | 9 | Dick Groat | 41%
|
| CF | 3 | Andy Van Slyke | 39%
|
| P | 5 | Bob Friend | 39%
|
| SS | 1 | Jack Wilson | 39%
|
| LF | 1 | Starling Marté | 39%
|
| P | 1 | Bob Walk | 38%
|
| 3B | 2 | Bill Madlock | 37%
|
| C | 3 | Manny Sanguillén | 35%
|
| P | 1 | Mitch Keller | 35%
|
| 3B | 1 | Pedro Álvarez | 35%
|
| C | 4 | Tony Peña | 35%
|
| P | 1 | A.J. Burnett | 34%
|
| P | 1 | Dock Ellis | 34%
|
| P | 1 | John Candelaria | 31%
|
| P | 1 | Kent Tekulve | 31%
|
| 3B | 2 | Pie Traynor | 31%
|
| OF | 3 | Al Oliver | 30%
|
| OF | 2 | Brian Giles | 28%
|
| 2B | 2 | Josh Harrison | 28%
|
| P | 2 | Mike Williams | 28%
|
| P | 3 | Vern Law | 27%
|
| SS | 8 | Arky Vaughan | 25%
|
| 2B | 3 | Freddy Sánchez | 25%
|
| P | 1 | Steve Blass | 24%
|
| 2B | 1 | Adam Frazier | 23%
|
| 1B | 1 | Jason Thompson | 23%
|
| P | 3 | Mark Melancon | 23%
|
| P | 2 | Bob Veale | 21%
|
| OF | 3 | Frank Thomas | 21%
|
| P | 1 | Jason Grilli | 21%
|
| P | 9 | Roy Face | 21%
|
| C | 10 | Smoky Burgess | 20%
|
| P | 2 | Joel Hanrahan | 17%
|
| OF | 2 | Matty Alou | 17%
|
| 1B | 3 | Dick Stuart | 15%
|
| 2B | 1 | Carlos García | 14%
|
| P | 1 | Rick Reuschel | 14%
|
| 2B | 2 | Phil Garner | 13%
|
| P | 1 | Zach Duke | 13%
|
| P | 2 | Felipe Vázquez | 11%
|
| SS | 2 | Gene Alley | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Jim Bibby | 11%
|
| P | 1 | John Smiley | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Mace Brown | 11%
|
| LF | 1 | Mike Easler | 11%
|
| OF | 1 | Nate McLouth | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Rick Rhoden | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Tony Watson | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Dave Giusti | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Denny Neagle | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Jeff Locke | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Jerry Reuss | 10%
|
| P | 4 | Rip Sewell | 10%
|
| LF | 4 | Bob Skinner | 8%
|
| P | 1 | Rich Gossage | 8%
|
| 2B | 1 | Tony Womack | 8%
|
| 3B | 1 | Ed Sprague | 7%
|
| 1B | 1 | Gus Suhr | 7%
|
| 1B | 1 | Dale Long | 6%
|
| P | 1 | Evan Meek | 6%
|
| P | 1 | Ken Brett | 6%
|
| CF | 2 | Vince DiMaggio | 6%
|
| 3B | 4 | Bob Elliott | 4%
|
| 2B | 3 | Frankie Gustine | 4%
|
| C | 1 | Hank Foiles | 4%
|
| P | 1 | Kevin Correia | 4%
|
| P | 1 | Murry Dickson | 4%
|
| C | 1 | Al López | 3%
|
| 1B | 1 | Elbie Fletcher | 3%
|
| P | 1 | Cy Blanton | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Elmer Riddie | 1%
|
| SS | 1 | Frankie Zak | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Neal Heaton | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Preacher Roe | 1%
|