| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1B | 10 | Albert Pujols | 93%
|
| C | 10 | Yadier Molina | 93%
|
| P | 3 | Adam Wainwright | 88%
|
| P | 10 | Bob Gibson | 87%
|
| SS | 14 | Ozzie Smith | 87%
|
| OF | 27 | Stan Musial | 85%
|
| C | 3 | Hal Smith | 83%
|
| P | 3 | Lee Smith | 83%
|
| LF | 1 | Lonnie Smith | 83%
|
| OF | 2 | Reggie Smith | 83%
|
| 3B | 3 | Matt Carpenter | 74%
|
| P | 3 | Chris Carpenter | 73%
|
| 1B | 1 | Paul Goldschmidt | 72%
|
| 3B | 3 | Nolan Arenado | 70%
|
| LF | 6 | Lou Brock | 65%
|
| CF | 2 | Jim Edmonds | 63%
|
| 3B | 4 | Scott Rolen | 55%
|
| 1B | 3 | Mark McGwire | 51%
|
| C | 6 | Ted Simmons | 50%
|
| OF | 4 | Willie McGee | 47%
|
| P | 4 | Dizzy Dean | 46%
|
| LF | 4 | Matt Holliday | 45%
|
| 1B | 2 | Keith Hernandez | 43%
|
| OF | 4 | Pepper Martin | 43%
|
| 2B | 1 | Stu Martin | 43%
|
| P | 2 | Bruce Sutter | 41%
|
| LF | 2 | Vince Coleman | 41%
|
| P | 2 | Carlos Martínez | 39%
|
| 3B | 10 | Ken Boyer | 38%
|
| P | 2 | Ryan Helsley | 38%
|
| 3B | 1 | David Freese | 37%
|
| RF | 10 | Enos Slaughter | 34%
|
| RF | 2 | Jack Clark | 34%
|
| OF | 1 | Lance Berkman | 33%
|
| SS | 1 | Paul DeJong | 33%
|
| CF | 3 | Curt Flood | 32%
|
| P | 1 | Miles Mikolas | 32%
|
| 2B | 1 | Tom Herr | 32%
|
| P | 1 | Bill Walker | 31%
|
| SS | 3 | Edgar Rentería | 31%
|
| CF | 1 | Harry Walker | 31%
|
| P | 3 | Steve Carlton | 30%
|
| P | 1 | Woody Williams | 30%
|
| CF | 2 | Carlos Beltrán | 29%
|
| SS | 2 | David Eckstein | 29%
|
| C | 4 | Joe Torre | 28%
|
| CF | 1 | Ray Lankford | 28%
|
| LF | 5 | Joe Medwick | 27%
|
| P | 1 | Jason Isringhausen | 26%
|
| 2B | 9 | Red Schoendienst | 26%
|
| C | 2 | Tim McCarver | 26%
|
| 1B | 11 | Bill White | 25%
|
| P | 4 | Larry Jackson | 25%
|
| P | 1 | Trevor Rosenthal | 24%
|
| 2B | 3 | Frankie Frisch | 23%
|
| P | 2 | Joaquín Andújar | 23%
|
| P | 1 | Lance Lynn | 23%
|
| P | 2 | Matt Morris | 23%
|
| 1B | 4 | Johnny Mize | 22%
|
| 1B | 1 | Orlando Cepeda | 22%
|
| SS | 1 | Rafael Furcal | 22%
|
| OF | 1 | Allen Craig | 21%
|
| SS | 2 | Garry Templeton | 21%
|
| SS | 1 | Jhonny Peralta | 20%
|
| C | 1 | Jimmie Wilson | 19%
|
| SS | 1 | Aledmys Díaz | 18%
|
| P | 1 | Michael Wacha | 18%
|
| C | 1 | Tony Peña | 18%
|
| OF | 1 | Ryan Ludwick | 17%
|
| C | 1 | Tom Pagnozzi | 17%
|
| P | 1 | Alex Reyes | 16%
|
| P | 1 | Curt Davis | 16%
|
| P | 1 | Darryl Kile | 16%
|
| OF | 2 | George Hendrick | 16%
|
| SS | 8 | Marty Marion | 15%
|
| 1B | 1 | Pedro Guerrero | 15%
|
| P | 1 | Todd Worrell | 15%
|
| 1B | 1 | Dick Allen | 14%
|
| 2B | 1 | Jimmy Brown | 14%
|
| 2B | 2 | Julián Javier | 14%
|
| P | 1 | Bob Tewksbury | 12%
|
| 1B | 2 | Gregg Jefferies | 12%
|
| 3B | 1 | Ken Reitz | 12%
|
| P | 2 | Mort Cooper | 12%
|
| SS | 1 | Royce Clayton | 12%
|
| C | 3 | Walker Cooper | 12%
|
| OF | 1 | Bake McBride | 11%
|
| SS | 2 | Dick Groat | 11%
|
| P | 1 | Rick Wise | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Ryan Franklin | 10%
|
| CF | 4 | Terry Moore | 10%
|
| P | 1 | Tom Henke | 10%
|
| RF | 1 | Félix José | 9%
|
| 1B | 2 | Ripper Collins | 8%
|
| P | 1 | Edward Mujica | 7%
|
| P | 1 | Kent Bottenfield | 7%
|
| P | 1 | Pat Neshek | 7%
|
| OF | 1 | Wally Moon | 7%
|
| C | 1 | Del Rice | 6%
|
| P | 3 | Harvey Haddix | 6%
|
| P | 3 | Lindy McDaniel | 6%
|
| 3B | 5 | Whitey Kurowski | 6%
|
| P | 2 | Harry Brecheen | 5%
|
| 1B | 3 | Joe Cunningham | 5%
|
| P | 3 | Vinegar Bend Mizell | 5%
|
| 2B | 1 | Don Blasingame | 4%
|
| P | 2 | Gerry Staley | 4%
|
| SS | 1 | Leo Durocher | 4%
|
| P | 1 | Lynn McGlothen | 4%
|
| P | 2 | Max Lanier | 4%
|
| 3B | 1 | Ray Jablonski | 4%
|
| OF | 1 | Rip Repulski | 4%
|
| 3B | 1 | Eddie Kazak | 3%
|
| P | 3 | Howie Pollet | 3%
|
| P | 2 | Lon Warneke | 3%
|
| P | 1 | Luis Arroyo | 3%
|
| P | 3 | Red Munger | 3%
|
| OF | 1 | Wally Westlake | 3%
|
| P | 1 | Bill Hallahan | 2%
|
| 2B | 1 | Burgess Whitehead | 2%
|
| 2B | 1 | Emil Verban | 1%
|
| C | 1 | Ken O'Dea | 1%
|
| P | 1 | Red Barrett | 1%
|