| Type | Name | Rating | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marquette | Dwayne Wade | 82 | 85%
|
| Marquette | Jimmy Butler | 90 | 85%
|
| Butler | Gordon Hayward | 88 | 77%
|
| Villanova | Kyle Lowry | 87 | 69%
|
| Creighton | Doug McDermott | 73 | 54%
|
| Providence | Kris Dunn | 72 | 54%
|
| Xavier | David West | 74 | 46%
|
| Georgetown | Greg Monroe | 80 | 46%
|
| Creighton | Kyle Korver | 74 | 46%
|
| Butler | Shelvin Mack | 73 | 46%
|
| Georgetown | Jeff Green | 73 | 38%
|
| Villanova | Josh Hart | 70 | 38%
|
| St. John's | Maurice Harkless | 74 | 38%
|
| Georgetown | Otto Porter, Jr. | 80 | 38%
|
| Marquette | Jae Crowder | 80 | 31%
|
| Xavier | Jordan Crawford | 73 | 31%
|
| DePaul | Wilson Chandler | 76 | 23%
|
| Providence | Ben Bentil | 66 | 15%
|
| Villanova | Dante Cunningham | 72 | 15%
|
| Creighton | Anthony Tolliver | 72 | 8%
|
| Seton Hall | Isaiah Whitehead | 73 | 8%
|
| St. John's | Jakarr Sampson | 69 | 8%
|
| St. John's | Metta World Peace | 70 | 8%
|
| Xavier | Semaj Christon | 70 | 8%
|