| College | Player | Rating | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marquette | Dwyane Wade | 97 | 90%
|
| Georgetown | Patrick Ewing | 95 | 90%
|
| Georgetown | Allen Iverson | 97 | 80%
|
| St. John's | Chris Mullin | 94 | 80%
|
| UConn | Caron Butler | 88 | 70%
|
| Butler | Gordon Hayward | 88 | 70%
|
| Marquette | Jimmy Butler | 91 | 70%
|
| Creighton | Doug McDermott | 78 | 60%
|
| UConn | Kemba Walker | 89 | 60%
|
| Butler | Sean McDermott | 69 | 60%
|
| Georgetown | Alonzo Mourning | 94 | 50%
|
| Providence | Kris Dunn | 76 | 50%
|
| Xavier | David West | 88 | 40%
|
| Villanova | Doug West | 85 | 40%
|
| Villanova | Kyle Lowry | 89 | 40%
|
| UConn | Ray Allen | 95 | 40%
|
| Creighton | Justin Patton | 72 | 30%
|
| Creighton | Kyle Korver | 84 | 30%
|
| DePaul | Mark Aguirre | 88 | 30%
|
| Xavier | Tyrone Hill | 76 | 20%
|
| DePaul | George Mikan | 94 | 10%
|
| St. John's | JaKarr Sampson | 73 | 10%
|
| St. John's | Mark Jackson | 85 | 10%
|
| Seton Hall | Adrian Griffin | 71 | 0%
|
| Xavier | James Posey | 80 | 0%
|
| Butler | Kelan Martin | 69 | 0%
|
| Villanova | Kerry Kittles | 82 | 0%
|
| Providence | Lenny Wilkens | 91 | 0%
|
| Seton Hall | Mark Bryant | 69 | 0%
|
| Marquette | Maurice Lucas | 90 | 0%
|
| Seton Hall | Myles Powell | 67 | 0%
|
| Providence | Otis Thorpe | 86 | 0%
|
| DePaul | Rod Strickland | 87 | 0%
|
| DePaul | Terry Cummings | 87 | 0%
|