| Role | Actor/Actress | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Jim, the "Waco Kid" | Gene Wilder | 93%
|
| Governor William J. Le Petomane/ Indian Chief | Mel Brooks | 93%
|
| Sheriff Bart | Cleavon Little | 71%
|
| Lili von Shtup | Madeline Kahn | 64%
|
| Taggart | Slim Pickens | 64%
|
| Hedley Lamarr | Harvey Korman | 57%
|
| Mongo | Alex Karras | 43%
|
| Buddy Bizarre | Dom DeLuise | 29%
|
| Howard Johnson | John Hillerman | 29%
|
| Lyle | Burton Gilliam | 21%
|
| Harriet Johnson | Carol Arthur | 21%
|
| Olson Johnson | David Huddleston | 21%
|
| Van Johnson | George Furth | 21%
|
| Gabby Johnson | Jack Starrett | 21%
|
| Reverend Johnson | Liam Dunn | 21%
|
| Dr. Samuel Johnson | Richard Collier | 21%
|
| Miss Stein, the Governor's Secretary | Robyn Hilton | 21%
|
| Charlie | Charles McGregor | 14%
|
| Extra in Church Congregation | Anne Bancroft | 7%
|
| Man in Commissary Playing Hitler | Ralph Manza | 7%
|
| Boris, the Hangman | Robert Ridgely | 7%
|
| Young Bart | Rodney Allen Rippey | 7%
|