| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Froze to death after falling through a frozen lake fleeing the police | Lester Nygaard | 83%
|
| Shot repeatedly by Gus Grimly | Lorne Malvo | 81%
|
| Stabbed in the back of the head by Lorne Malvo | Sam Hess | 81%
|
| Beaten to death with a hammer by Lester Nygaard | Pearl Nygaard | 79%
|
| Throat slit by Lorne Malvo | Mr. Numbers | 35%
|
| Shot in the head by Lorne Malvo while on watch outside Lester Nygaard's house | Agent Pepper / Agent Budge | 27%
|
| Killed in car crash after fish rain from the sky | Dmitri Milos | 21%
|
| Shotgunned in the back by Lorne Malvo | Vern Thurman | 21%
|
| Shot in the back of the head by Lorne Malvo while wearing Lester Nygaard's coat | Linda Park | 17%
|
| Shot to death by police officers while taped to a shotgun and an exercise bench | Don Chumph | 13%
|