| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Bay Habour Butcher | Dexter Morgan | 100%
|
| Dexter's Sister | Debra Morgan | 98%
|
| Dexter's Adoptive Father | Harry Morgan | 96%
|
| Dexter's Wife | Rita Bennett | 96%
|
| Lieutenant / Captain (Season 1-8) | Maria Laguerta | 95%
|
| Detective / Lieutenant (Season 1-8) | Angel Batista | 94%
|
| Detective (Season 1-2) | James Doakes | 91%
|
| Forensic Examiner (Season 1-8) | Vince Masuka | 90%
|
| Ice Truck Killer | Brian Moser/Rudy Cooper | 88%
|
| Dexter's Son | Harrison Morgan | 87%
|
| Detective (Season 3-8) | Joey Quinn | 86%
|
| Dexter's Stepson | Cody Bennett | 82%
|
| FBI Special Agent (Season 2, 4) | Frank Lundy | 82%
|
| Dexter's Stepdaughter | Astor Bennett | 78%
|
| Dexter's Mistress (Season 2) | Lila West | 78%
|
| Dexter's Biological Mother (Season 1) | Laura Moser | 74%
|
| Trinity Killer (Season 4) | Arthur Mitchell | 73%
|
| Rita's Ex-husband (Season 1-2) | Paul Bennett | 71%
|
| Assistant District Attorney | Miguel Prado | 64%
|
| Barrel Girl #13 (Season 5) | Lumen Pierce | 61%
|
| Captain (Season 1-2), Deputy Chief (4-6) | Tom Matthews | 56%
|
| Dexter's Love Interest (Season 7) | Hannah McKay | 54%
|
| Doomsday Killer | Travis Marshall | 51%
|
| Motivational Speaker (Season 5) | Jordan Chase | 49%
|
| Dexter's Sister's Boyfriend (Season 3) | Anton Briggs | 47%
|
| Dexter's Babysitter (Season 6-7) | Jamie Batista | 47%
|
| Ukrainian Mob Boss Season 7 | Isaak Sirko | 43%
|
| The Brain Surgeon | Daniel Vogel / Oliver Saxon | 42%
|
| Trinity Killer's Son (Season 4) | Jonah Mitchell | 41%
|
| The Psychopath Whisperer | Dr Evelyn Vogel | 34%
|
| The Skinner (Season 3) | Jorge Orozco / George Washington King | 34%
|
| Manager of 'The Fox Hole' (Season 7) | George Novikov | 33%
|
| Miguel's Brother (Season 3) | Ramon Prado | 33%
|
| Trinity's Killer's Daughter (Season 4) | Christine Hill | 29%
|
| Detective (Season 6-7) | Mike Anderson | 28%
|
| Defense Attorney (Season 3) | Ellen Wolf | 27%
|
| Doomsday Killer Mentor | James Gellar | 27%
|
| Reformed Criminal (Season 6) | Brother Sam | 26%
|
| Trinity Killer's Daughter | Rebecca Mitchell | 25%
|
| Dexter's Apprentice (S8) | Zach Hamilton | 22%
|
| Dexter's Neighbour | Elliot | 21%
|
| Stripper (Season 7) | Nadia | 21%
|
| Forensic Intern (Season 6-7) | Louis Greene | 20%
|
| Isaak's lover (Season 7) | Viktor Baskov | 19%
|
| True Crimes Writer (Season 7) | Sal Price | 17%
|
| Lieutenant (Season 1) | Esme Pascal | 16%
|
| Corrupt Narcotics Officer (Season 5) | Stan Liddy | 16%
|
| Dexter's Sister's Boyfriend (Season 2) | Gabriel | 14%
|
| Dexter's Sister's Boss (S8) | Jacob Elway | 13%
|
| Trinity Killer's Wife | Sally Mitchell | 12%
|
| Internal Affairs Officer (Season 3) | Yuki Amado | 10%
|
| Dexter's Neighbour (S8) | Cassie Jollenston | 8%
|
| Detective (S7-8) | Angie Miller | 6%
|
| Forensic Examiner's Daughter | Niki Walters | 6%
|
| Dexter's Babysitter (Season 5) | Sonya | 6%
|
| Forensic Intern (Season 6) | Ryan Chambers | 5%
|
| Deputy Marshall (S8) | Clayton | 4%
|
| Rookie cop (Season 5) | Cira Manzon | 3%
|
| Dexter's Sister's Therapist | Michelle Ross | 1%
|