| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Main Protagonist | Arthur Morgan | 98%
|
| Charismatic Leader | Dutch van der Linde | 95%
|
| Secondary Protagonist | John Marston | 94%
|
| Snitch, Eventual Antagonist | Micah Bell | 93%
|
| Son Of The Above | Jack Marston | 92%
|
| Wife Of The Above | Abigail Marston | 90%
|
| Master Con-man, Closest Friend of the Above | Hosea Matthews | 90%
|
| Widow, Rescued in the Prologue | Sadie Adler | 89%
|
| Hot-headed Ex Soldier | Bill Williamson | 84%
|
| Mexican Gang Member | Javier Escuella | 84%
|
| Native American Gang Member | Charles Smith | 80%
|
| Killed During the St. Denis Bank Job | Lenny Summers | 78%
|
| The Camp Cook, Ex Navy | Simon Pearson | 77%
|
| Camp Loan Shark | Leopold Strauss | 76%
|
| Cocky, Irish, Rescued During the Early Game | Sean MacGuire | 76%
|
| Leader of the Rival Gang | Colm O'Driscoll | 73%
|
| Conman, Not Always At Camp | Josiah Trelawny | 72%
|
| Formerly With the Foreman Brothers Gang | Tilly Jackson | 71%
|
| Petty Thief, Drunk, Also Features in RDR1 | Uncle | 71%
|
| Wealthy Entrepreneur, Often Robbed by the Gang | Leviticus Cornwall | 69%
|
| Boss of the Camp | Susan Grimshaw | 69%
|
| Love Interest of the Charismatic Leader | Molly O'Shea | 68%
|
| Former RIval Gang Member | Kieran Duffy | 66%
|
| Son of the Above | Eagle Flies | 64%
|
| Scam Artist, Actress | Karen Jones | 62%
|
| Former Clergyman, Drug Addict | Orville Swanson | 62%
|
| Lawman, Main Antagonist | Andrew Milton | 61%
|
| Native American Chief | Rains Fall | 61%
|
| Kind, Good Natured Young Woman | Mary-Beth Gaskill | 58%
|
| Ex-fiancée of the Main Protagnist | Mary Linton | 57%
|
| Subordinate to the Above | Edgar Ross | 56%
|
| Italian Buisnessman and Crimelord | Angelo Bronte | 52%
|
| Brother of the Above | Mac Callander | 51%
|
| In Debt to the Gang, Has Tuberculosis | Thomas Downes | 51%
|
| Dies During the Prologue | Davey Callander | 50%
|
| Secret Lover of the Above | Beauregard "Beau" Gray | 46%
|
| Matriarch of One of the Feuding Families in Rhodes | Catherine Braithwaite | 45%
|
| Female, Died After the Blackwater Job | Jenny Kirk | 44%
|
| Daughter of the Above | Penelope Braithwaite | 44%
|
| Wife of the Above | Edith Downes | 42%
|
| Uncle of the Above | Leigh Gray | 40%
|
| Right-Hand Man of the Above | Levi Simon | 39%
|
| Son of the Above | Archie Downes | 36%
|
| Guarma Antagonist | Alberto Fussar | 34%
|
| Joins the Gang in the Final Chapter, Interrogated in the Epilogue | Cleet | 31%
|
| Colonel, Cruel Towards Native Americans | Henry Favours | 30%
|
| Also Joins the Gang in the Final Chapter | Joe | 29%
|
| Close Friend of the Above | Paytah | 29%
|
| US Army Officer, Assisting the Natives | Captain Lyndon Monroe | 24%
|
| Mayor of Saint Denis | Henri Lemieux | 24%
|
| Brother of the Above | Jamie Gillis | 23%
|
| A Monk in Saint Denis, Helps the Poor | Brother Dorkins | 21%
|
| Famous Author, Sympathises With the Natives | Evelyn Miller | 20%
|
| A Nun in Saint Denis | Sister Calderón | 20%
|
| Female Gunslinger | Black Belle | 19%
|
| Ranch Owner in the Epilogue | David Geddes | 19%
|
| Youngest Son of the Ranch Owner | Duncan Geddes | 19%
|
| Eldest Son of the Ranch Owner | Angus Geddes | 18%
|
| Fastest Left-Handed Draw in the West, Found With the Above | Jim "Boy" Calloway | 18%
|
| Retired Gunslinger, Pig Farmer | Emmet Granger | 14%
|
| Infamous Mexican Outlaw and Gunslinger | Flaco Hernández | 14%
|
| One-Legged Outdoorsman, Friend of the Protagonist | Hamish Sinclair | 13%
|
| Serbian Inventor/Professor | Marko Dragic | 13%
|
| Helps the Gang Escape Guarma | Hercule Fontaine | 11%
|
| Amatuer Wildlife Photographer | Albert Mason | 8%
|
| French Artist | Charles Châtenay | 8%
|
| Timetravelling Collector, Birthmark On His Face | Francis Sinclair | 8%
|
| Widow, the Protagonist Teaches Her how to Survive in the Wild | Charlotte Balfour | 6%
|
| Cross-Dressing Animal Wrangler | Haywood Margaret | 6%
|
| Author, Writing a Book About Famous Gunslingers | Theodore Levin | 6%
|
| Asks the Protagonist to Bring Him Various Exotic Materials | Algernon Wasp | 4%
|
| Distant Cousin of the Ranch Owner, Banker | Ansel Atherton | 4%
|
| Redundant Ex Slave Catcher | Jeremiah Compson | 4%
|
| An Elder in Butcher Creek | Obediah Hinton | 4%
|
| One-Armed Guarma Rebel | Baptiste | 3%
|
| Woman Who Asks the Protagonist to Find Dinosaur Bones | Deborah MacGuiness | 3%
|
| Love Interest of Competing Twins | Helen | 3%
|
| Deputy Mayor of Saint Denis | Jean Marc Mercier | 3%
|
| The Other Competing Twin, Wears Yellow | Acrisius | 2%
|
| Encourages the Protagonist to Collect Cigarette Cards | Phineas T. Ramsbottom | 2%
|
| Helps the Main Protagonist Rescue Some Workers Fron the Gallows on Guarma | Leon Fuentes | 1%
|
| One of the Competing Twins, Wears Blue | Proetus | 1%
|
| Assistant to the Above | Sally Nash | 1%
|
| Travelling Doctor, His Wagon Gets Stolen | Alphonse Renaud | 0%
|
| Former Gunslinger/National Celebrity | Billy Midnignt | 0%
|