| Island | Population | Country | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| North Island | 4,000,000 | New Zealand | 100%
|
| South Island | 1,200,000 | New Zealand | 100%
|
| New Guinea | 14,800,000 | Indonesia/PNG | 97%
|
| Tasmania | 540,000 | Australia | 91%
|
| New Caledonia | 250,000 | France | 86%
|
| Guam | 150,000 | United States | 69%
|
| Hawaii | 200,000 | United States | 66%
|
| Oahu | 1,000,000 | United States | 66%
|
| Tahiti | 180,000 | France | 60%
|
| Bougainville | 230,000 | Papua New Guinea | 54%
|
| Maui | 160,000 | United States | 51%
|
| New Britain | 510,000 | Papua New Guinea | 46%
|
| Viti Levu | 660,000 | Fiji | 46%
|
| New Ireland | 190,000 | Papua New Guinea | 43%
|
| Kauai | 73,000 | United States | 40%
|
| Vanua Levu | 130,000 | Fiji | 37%
|
| Guadalcanal | 160,000 | Solomon Islands | 29%
|
| Tarawa | 70,000 | Kiribati | 26%
|
| Manus | 50,000 | Papua New Guinea | 17%
|
| Tongatapu | 75,000 | Tonga | 11%
|
| Upolu | 150,000 | Samoa | 11%
|
| Efate | 66,000 | Vanuatu | 9%
|
| Biak | 110,000 | Indonesia | 6%
|
| Malaita | 140,000 | Solomon Islands | 6%
|