| State (Party) | Senator | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Massachusetts (R) | Henry Wilson | 100%
|
| Virginia (R) | John F. Lewis | 100%
|
| Kentucky (D) | John W. Stevenson | 100%
|
| Texas (R) | Morgan C. Hamilton | 100%
|
| Indiana (R) | Oliver H. P. T. Morton | 100%
|
| Maryland (D) | William T. Hamilton | 100%
|
| Mississippi (R) | Adelbert Ames | 50%
|
| Ohio (R) | Allen G. Thurman | 50%
|
| Arkansas (R) | Benjamin F. Rice | 50%
|
| Massachusetts (R) | Charles Sumner | 50%
|
| Delaware (D) | Eli M. Saulsbury | 50%
|
| California (D) | Eugene Casserly | 50%
|
| Missouri (D) | Francis P. Blair Jr. | 50%
|
| South Carolina (R) | Frederick A. Sawyer | 50%
|
| New Jersey (R) | Frederick T. Frelinghuysen | 50%
|
| Alabama (R) | George E. Spencer | 50%
|
| Iowa (R) | George G. Wright | 50%
|
| Maryland (D) | George Vickers | 50%
|
| Rhode Island (R) | Henry B. Anthony | 50%
|
| Iowa (R) | James Harlan | 50%
|
| Mississippi (R) | James L. Alcorn | 50%
|
| Texas (R) | James W. Flanagan | 50%
|
| New Hampshire (R) | James W. Patterson | 50%
|
| Illinois (R) | John A. Logan | 50%
|
| North Carolina (R) | John Pool | 50%
|
| Pennsylvania (R) | John Scott | 50%
|
| Ohio (R) | John Sherman | 50%
|
| Virginia (D) | John W. Johnston | 50%
|
| Georgia (R) | Joshua Hill | 50%
|
| Louisiana (R) | J. Rodman West | 50%
|
| Vermont (R) | Justin S. Morrill | 50%
|
| Maine (R) | Lot M. Morrill | 50%
|
| Illinois (LR) | Lyman Trumbull | 50%
|
| Connecticut (R) | Orris S. Ferry | 50%
|
| Nebraska (R) | Phineas Hitchcock | 50%
|
| Arkansas (R) | Powell Clayton | 50%
|
| New York (R) | Roscoe Conkling | 50%
|
| Kansas (R) | Samuel C. Pomeroy | 50%
|
| Pennsylvania (R) | Simon Cameron | 50%
|
| South Carolina (R) | Thomas J. Robertson | 50%
|
| Michigan (R) | Thomas W. Ferry | 50%
|
| Florida (R) | Thomas W. Osborn | 50%
|
| Wisconsin (R) | Timothy O. Howe | 50%
|
| Louisiana (R)* | William P. Kellogg | 50%
|
| Minnesota (R) | William Windom | 50%
|
| Kentucky (D) | Willis B. Machen | 50%
|
| New Hampshire (R) | Aaron H. Cragin | 0%
|
| Florida (R) | Abijah Gilbert | 0%
|
| Kansas (R) | Alexander Caldwell | 0%
|
| Minnesota (R) | Alexander Ramsey | 0%
|
| West Virginia (R) | Arthur I. Boreman | 0%
|
| Missouri (R) | Carl Schurz | 0%
|
| California (R) | Cornelius Cole | 0%
|
| Indiana (R) | Daniel D. Pratt | 0%
|
| Kentucky (D)* | Garrett Davis | 0%
|
| Vermont (R) | George F. Edmunds | 0%
|
| Alabama (D) | George Goldthwaite | 0%
|
| Maine (R) | Hannibal Hamlin | 0%
|
| Tennessee (D) | Henry Cooper | 0%
|
| West Virginia (D) | Henry G. Davis | 0%
|
| Oregon (R) | Henry W. Corbertt | 0%
|
| Oregon (D) | James K. Kelly | 0%
|
| Nevada (R) | James W. Nye | 0%
|
| New Jersey (D) | John P. Stockton | 0%
|
| Wisconsin (R) | Matthew H. Carpenter | 0%
|
| North Carolina (D) | Matt W. Ransom | 0%
|
| New York (R) | Reuben Fenton | 0%
|
| Delaware (D) | Thomas F. Bayard Sr. | 0%
|
| Georgia (D) | Thomas M. Norwood | 0%
|
| Nebraska (R) | Thomas Tipton | 0%
|
| Connecticut (R) | William A. Buckingham | 0%
|
| Tennessee (R) | William G. Brownlow | 0%
|
| Nevada (R) | William M. Stewart | 0%
|
| Rhode Island (R) | William Sprague | 0%
|
| Michigan (R) | Zachariah Chandler | 0%
|