| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Eldest Winchester brother | Dean Winchester | 100%
|
| Youngest Winchester brother | Sam Winchester | 100%
|
| Father of the Winchester brothers | John Winchester | 98%
|
| Mother of the Winchester brothers | Mary Winchester | 98%
|
| Angel who wear a dirty trenchcoat | Castiel | 94%
|
| Half-brother of the Winchester brothers | Adam Milligan | 92%
|
| Maternal grandfather of the Winchester brothers | Samuel Campbell | 87%
|
| King of Hell | Crowley | 86%
|
| Archangel who left Heaven and used the alias 'The Trickster' | Gabriel | 83%
|
| Female Demon who willingly gives the youngest Winchester brother her blood | Ruby | 83%
|
| Archangel that was the first Angel to fall | Lucifer | 82%
|
| The Winchester brother's Mentor | Bobby Singer | 79%
|
| Demon who had to be killed to break the final seal | Lilith | 79%
|
| First female Demon seen | Meg | 77%
|
| Eldest and most powerful Archangel | Michael | 77%
|
| Archangel who shares the name of a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle | Raphael | 77%
|
| Yellow Eyed Demon | Azazel | 75%
|
| Hunter who co-owned the Roadhouse and daughter of ^ | Jo Harvelle | 75%
|
| Hunter who co-owned the Roadhouse | Ellen Harvelle | 72%
|
| One of the Horsemen beginning with D | Death | 71%
|
| Angel who fell from Heaven | Anna | 70%
|
| Hunter that worked in the Roadhouse | Ash | 66%
|
| Hunter that created the famous gun 'Colt' that can kill almost everything | Samuel Colt | 65%
|
| Angel who stole Heaven's weapons | Balthazar | 64%
|
| One of the Horsemen beginning with W | War | 64%
|
| One of the Horsemen beginning with F | Famine | 57%
|
| Prophet first season in season 7 | Kevin Tran | 56%
|
| Prophet first seen in season 4 | Chuck Shurley | 54%
|
| Hunter that hunted with the Winchester brother's Mentor | Rufus Turner | 54%
|
| Angel who tried to force the eldest Winchester brother to say yes to his Archangel | Zachariah | 54%
|
| Maternal grandmother of the Winchester brothers | Deanna Campbell | 52%
|
| Leader of the Leviathans | Dick Roman | 52%
|
| Hunter that helped hunt with the eldest Winchester brother in season 7 | Garth Fitzgerald IV | 51%
|
| Paternal grandfather of the Winchester brothers | Henry Winchester | 51%
|
| Angel who was said to be a 'specialist' | Uriel | 50%
|
| Hunter who can hack anything | Charlie Bradbury | 49%
|
| Demon who taught the eldest Winchester brother to torture in Hell | Alastair | 47%
|
| One of the Horsemen beginning with P | Pestilence | 43%
|
| Knight of Hell | Abaddon | 41%
|