| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| What mark does the Darkness have on her chest? | The Mark of Cain | 94%
|
| Who is Chuck? | God | 85%
|
| What kind of monster is Alex's boyfriend in "Don't You Forget About Me"? | Vampire | 85%
|
| Who becomes Lucifer's new vessel in "The Devil in the Details"? | Castiel | 78%
|
| Which of the actors directed "The Bad Seed"? | Jensen Ackles | 76%
|
| What is Amara's relationship to Chuck? | She is his sister | 76%
|
| Which sheriff calls upon the boys for help with a case in "Plush"? | Donna Hanscum | 72%
|
| Who returns to Heaven to assert their dominance in "Hell's Angel" | Lucifer | 72%
|
| What holiday is it in "Love Hurts"? | Valentine's Day | 72%
|
| Which season 4 and 5 regular returns in "Don't Call Me Shurley"? | Chuck Shurley | 70%
|
| What is the name of the episode shown completely from the point of view of the Impala? | Baby | 69%
|
| Who did the same case as Sam and Dean years before them in "Safe House"? | Bobby and Rufus | 67%
|
| Who is Sully in "Just My Imagination"? | Sam's childhood imaginary friend | 67%
|
| Whose grave do Sam and Dean visit before they part, seemingly for the last time in "Alpha and Omega"? | Mary Winchester | 64%
|
| Who returns from the dead in the last scene of the finale? | Mary Winchester | 63%
|
| Who briefly dies in "Red Meat"? | Dean | 58%
|
| What is the name of the new prophet in "All in the Family"? | Donatello | 58%
|
| Who kissed Dean in "O Brother, Where Art Thou"? | Amara | 57%
|
| Where does Sam get trapped in "O Brother, Where Art Thou"? | Lucifer's Cage | 46%
|
| Finish the Quote: "No ___________ moments." "You love ___________ moments". | Chick flick | 39%
|
| Finish the Quote: "Turns out I did shoot the ______" | Deputy | 37%
|
| Which old villain from season 9 returned in "Our Little World"? | Metatron | 37%
|
| How many years separate the disappearances in "The Chitters"? | 27 | 36%
|
| Who fight at the end of "We Happy Few"? | Chuck and Amara | 36%
|
| What year does Casifer send Dean back to in "The Vessel"? | 1944 | 34%
|
| Finish the Quote: "Just a couple of hours ago, I killed _____. I'm pretty much open for anything". | Death | 33%
|
| Who is the title "Thin Lizzie" an allusion to? | Lizzie Borden | 33%
|
| Why do Sam and Dean rescue Lucifer from Amara? | To protect Castiel | 30%
|
| What age is Amara in "Form and Void"? | A baby | 25%
|
| Finish the Quote: "Like a magic STD. Okay, that works. Kind of makes you nostalgic for good, old-fashioned ________" | Herpes | 13%
|
| Finish the Quote: ""Wait, so only ___________ get to see him? And this makes sense to billions of you?" | Dead people | 9%
|
| Whose funeral do Sam and Dean attend in "Beyond the Mat"? | Larry Lee | 7%
|
| What do victims hear before dying in "Into the Mystic"? | A song | 3%
|