| Country | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Canada | Baffin | 89%
|
| Haiti + Dominican Republic | Hispaniola | 77%
|
| United States | Hawaii | 70%
|
| Bahamas | North Andros | 27%
|
| Mexico | Tiburon | 9%
|
| Honduras | Roatan | 7%
|
| Belize | Turneffe Atoll | 7%
|
| Costa Rica | Chira | 5%
|
| Nicaragua | Ometepe | 5%
|
| Panama | Coiba | 2%
|