| Actor | Description of Character | Name of Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas Gibson | BAU Unit Chief, has one son, Doesn´t come back to the BAU after season 12 | Aaron Hotchner | 99%
|
| Kirsten Vangsness | Excentric technical analystof the team | Penelope Garcia | 99%
|
| Matthew Gray Gubler | Highly intelligent, has an eidetic memory and several doctorates | Dr. Spencer Reid | 98%
|
| Shemar Moore | His father got killed on duty as a Chicago policemen, has a special relationship to the teams technical analyst | Derek Morgan | 97%
|
| A. J. Cook | Gets two sons during the series, Will becomes her husband. At the beginning she was public relations specialist, but then became profiler | Jennifer Jareau | 97%
|
| Joe Mantegna | Founding member of the BAU, he is a famous author coming back to the BAU from pension | David Rossi | 96%
|
| Paget Brewster | Daughter of a diplomat, speaks several languages. She fakes her death in order to escape a murderer. Becomes Unit Chief in season 12 | Emily Prentiss | 96%
|
| Mandy Patinkin | One of the BAU´s founders, gets murdered in Season 10 | Jason Gideon | 95%
|
| Lola Glaudini | Gets shot and injured in season 1, murders a criminal in season 2 and leaves the Unit after season 2 | Elle Greenaway | 84%
|
| Adam Rodriguez | Since season 12, lets a fleeing suspect fall to death from a rooftop instead of saving him | Luke Alvez | 79%
|
| Daniel Henney | Joins the BAU in season 13 after having worked for the International Response Team | Matthew Simmons | 75%
|
| Jeanne Tripplehorn | 8.-9. season, her son dies at age 9, Her husband works for médecins sans frontières | Dr. Alex Blake | 73%
|
| Aisha Tyler | Psychologist from San Francisco | Dr. Tara Lewis | 69%
|
| Nicholas Brendon | Auxiliary for technical analyst.He has a short love affair with her and helps her on several cases | Kevin Lynch | 64%
|
| Rachel Nichols | Replacement for a colleague during season 6, daughter of a serial killer | Ashley Seaver | 63%
|
| Jennifer Love Hewitt | Works for the BAU in season 10, her sister died at 9/11. | Kate Callahan | 61%
|
| Damon Gupton | Joins the BAU in season 12, has beenUndercover-Agent before that, gets murdered in season 13 | Stephen Walker | 52%
|
| Meta Golding | Replaces a colleague during maternity protection in season 4 | Jordan Todd | 51%
|