| # | Songwriter(s) | Most popular performer | Song | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Maria Carey,Walter Afanasieff | Mariah Carey | All I Want For Christmas Is You | 83%
|
| 15 | George Michael | Wham! | Last Christmas | 76%
|
| 7 | Irving Berlin | Bing Crosby | White Christmas | 61%
|
| 6 | Johnny Marks | Brenda Lee | Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree | 53%
|
| 8 | Joseph Beal,James Boothe | Bobby Helms | Jingle Bell Rock | 50%
|
| 19 | James Pierpont | Frank Sinatra | Jingle Bells | 44%
|
| 18 | Johnny Marks | Gene Autry | Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer | 36%
|
| 20 | Joan Jevits,Philip Springe | Eartha Kitt | Santa Baby | 34%
|
| 4 | Sammy Cahn,Jule Styne | Dean Martin | Let It Snow, Let It Snow, Let It Snow | 33%
|
| 11 | Mel Torme,Robert Wells | Nat King Cole | The Christmas Song | 33%
|
| 16 | Franz Gruber,Joseph Mohr | Bing Crosby | Silent Night | 30%
|
| 13 | J. Fred Coots,Haven Gillespie | Jackson 5 | Santa Claus Is Comin' To Town | 28%
|
| 5 | Leroy Andersen,Mitchell Parish | The Ronettes | Sleigh Ride | 27%
|
| 17 | Edward Pole,George Wyle | Andy Williams | It's The Most Wonderful Time Of The Year | 26%
|
| 3 | Meredith Wilson | Michael Buble | It's Beginning To Look A Lot like Christmas | 25%
|
| 10 | Felix Bernard,Richard Smith | Darlene Love | Winter Wonderland | 25%
|
| 9 | Johnny Marks | Burl Ives | Have A Holly Jolly Christmas | 19%
|
| 2 | Hugh Martin,Ralph Blane | Michael Buble | Have Yourself A Very Merry Little Christmas | 14%
|
| 14 | Kim Gannon,Walter Kent | Michael Buble | I'll Be Home For Christmas | 11%
|
| 12 | Jeff Barry,Ellie Greenwich, Phil Spector | Darlene Love | Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) | 10%
|