| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Somewhat evil vampire brother | Damon Salvatore | 100%
|
| Female lead | Elena Gilbert | 97%
|
| Good vampire brother | Stefan Salvatore | 97%
|
| Werewolf | Tyler Lockwood | 97%
|
| History teacher and vampire hunter | Alaric Saltzman | 96%
|
| Female witch | Bonnie Bennet | 96%
|
| Lead characters younger brother | Jeremy Gilbert | 96%
|
| Main characters aunt | Jenna Sommers | 95%
|
| Evil vampire doppelganger | Katherine Pierce | 95%
|
| Main Villain | Klaus Mikaelson | 95%
|
| Female vampire friend | Caroline Forbes | 94%
|
| Most moral Original vampire | Elijah Mikaelson | 93%
|
| Sheriff in town | Liz Forbes | 93%
|
| Jock who used to date the lead female | Matt Donovan | 92%
|
| Another vampire original | Rebekah Mikaelson | 91%
|
| Charismatic Original vampire | Kol Mikaelson | 86%
|
| Vampire hater and main characters father | John Gilbert | 85%
|
| Good brothers best friend | Lexi Branson | 85%
|
| Whitmore Doctor | Jo Laughlin | 82%
|
| Werewolf uncle | Mason Lockwood | 79%
|
| The Original witch | Esther Mikaelson | 78%
|
| Petrova doppelganger child | Nadia Petrova | 78%
|
| Season 6 sociopath witch | Kai Parker | 76%
|
| Vampire hunter Original | Mikael | 74%
|
| Vampire hating Original | Finn Mikaelson | 73%
|
| Female witch twin | Liv Parker | 73%
|
| Male witch twin | Luke Parker | 72%
|
| First vampire girlfriend staked in the heart | Vicki Donovan | 72%
|
| Second vampire girlfriend staked in the heart | Anna | 66%
|
| Most powerful "Vampire" | Silas | 63%
|
| Mother rescued from the vampire tomb | Pearl | 60%
|
| Vampire who sired Katherine | Rose | 52%
|
| Ancient witch ghost | Emily | 41%
|
| Owner of Whitmore | Aaron Whitmore | 38%
|
| Evil vampire mother | Isobel | 37%
|
| Most powerful witch | Qetsiyah | 36%
|
| The Huntress | Rayna | 36%
|
| Professor Creepy-Pants | Atticus Shane | 34%
|
| Augustine scientist | Wes Maxfield | 28%
|
| The Devil | Arcadius | 26%
|
| Werewolf girl | Haley | 24%
|
| The Brotherhood of the Five | Conner | 4%
|