| Performers | Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Kingsley; Jay Levey | leader | Gandhi | 74%
|
| Charlie Chaplin^; Anthony Hopkins | politician | Adolf Hitler | 61%
|
| John Cusack; Kevin Spacey* | president | Richard Nixon | 56%
|
| Henry Fonda; Brendan Fraser | president | Abraham Lincoln | 53%
|
| Robert Downey Jr.; Eddie Izzard | actor | Charlie Chaplin | 47%
|
| Kirk Douglas; Val Kilmer | gunslinger | Doc Holliday | 45%
|
| John Schneider; Sean William Scott | good ol' boy | Bo Duke | 36%
|
| Kurt Russell; Don Johnson | musician | Elvis Presley | 35%
|
| Nicol Williamson; David Warner | wizard | Merlin | 35%
|
| Olivia Williams; Nina Young | goddess | Hera | 34%
|
| William Daniels; Paul Giamatti | president | John Adams | 33%
|
| Ashley Judd; Mira Sorvino | actress | Marilyn Monroe | 31%
|
| Harry Hamlin; Sam Worthington | hero | Perseus | 24%
|
| Juliette Lewis; Leslie Mann* | vacationer | Audrey Griswold | 23%
|
| Julia Ormond; Keira Knightley | queen | Guinevere | 20%
|
| Bill Murray^; Jim Carrey | rich person | Ebenezer Scrooge | 19%
|
| Emmy Rossum; Jennifer Love Hewitt | actress | Audrey Hepburn | 15%
|
| Paul McCartney; Jack Black | musician | Paul McCartney | 15%
|
| Kevin Kline; Tom Skerritt | president | Ulysses S. Grant | 10%
|
| Aaron Paul; Andy Samberg | musician | Weird Al Yankovic | 3%
|