| Actors | Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neil Patrick Harris; Tom Holland | superhero | Spider-man | 72%
|
| Teri Hatcher; Kate Bosworth | reporter | Lois Lane | 49%
|
| Morgan Freeman; Mario van Peebles | activist | Malcolm X | 39%
|
| Peter Cushing; James McAvoy | doctor | Dr. Frankentein | 32%
|
| Joseph Fiennes; Patrick Stewart | writer | William Shakespeare | 27%
|
| Christopher Lambert; Tony Goldwyn | primatologist | Tarzan | 26%
|
| David Hasselhoff; Dwayne Johnson | lifeguard | Mitch Buchannon | 25%
|
| Dennis Quaid; Randy Quaid | gunslinger | Doc Holliday | 22%
|
| Max von Sydow; Christopher Waltz | evil genius | Ernst Stavro Blofeld | 14%
|
| Adrienne Barbeau; Juliette Binoche | witness | Mary Magdalene | 13%
|
| Verne Troyer; Warwick Davis | goblin | Griphook | 11%
|
| Charles Dance; Gerard Butler | freak | Phantom of the Opera | 11%
|
| Rachel Ward; Sigourney Weaver | queen | Isabella | 8%
|
| Phil LaMarr; Joseph Fiennes | entertainer | Michael Jackson | 8%
|
| Tim Curry; Jack Nicholson | villain | The Devil | 8%
|
| Lance Henrickson; Marlon Brando | inquisitor | Tomás de Torquemada | 7%
|
| Sarah Brightman; Emmy Rossum | singer | Christine Daaé | 5%
|
| James McAvoy; Michael Fassbender | lord | MacBeth | 5%
|
| Brian Cox; Danny Huston | bigot | William Stryker | 5%
|
| Burt Reynolds; Brian Cox | actor | Marlon Brando | 2%
|