| Actors | Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Helen Mirren; Claire Foy | queen | Queen Elizabeth II | 92%
|
| Robin Williams; Will Smith | wishgiver | Genie | 75%
|
| Eddie Murphy; Robert Downey Jr. | animal whisperer | Doctor Dolittle | 70%
|
| Tim Allen; Kurt Russell | overweight elf | Santa Claus | 60%
|
| Jeremy Brett; Will Ferrell | detective | Sherlock Holmes | 56%
|
| Jodie Whittaker; Colin Baker | time traveler | The Doctor | 55%
|
| Lorenzo Music; Bill Murray | cool cat | Garfield (and Peter Venkman) | 50%
|
| Frank Caliendo; Sam Rockwell | president | George W Bush | 50%
|
| Wesley Snipes; Mahershala Ali* | daywalker | Blade | 45%
|
| Ron Perlman; David Harbour | superhero | Hellboy | 39%
|
| Harrison Ford; John Krasinski | agent | Jack Ryan | 38%
|
| John Goodman; Bill Murray | singing bear | Baloo | 37%
|
| Rooney Mara; Claire Foy | hacker | Lisbeth Salander | 30%
|
| Rowan Atkinson; John Oliver | neurotic bird | Zazu | 27%
|
| Glen Close; Emma Stone* | animal lover | Cruela DeVil | 26%
|
| Hillary Duff; Margot Robbie | actress | Sharon Tate | 26%
|
| Harvey Keitel; Michael Shannon | musician | Elvis Presley | 21%
|
| Scott Glenn; Steve Carell | secretary of defense | Donald Rumsfeld | 17%
|
| Jimmi Simpson; Ed Harris | faux cowboy | William (the Man in Black) | 6%
|
| Claire Danes; Bryce Dallas Howard | famous wife | Kate Connor/Katherine Brewster | 4%
|