| Actor | Portrayals | Role | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Daniel Radcliffe | 8, 2001-2011 | Harry Potter | 99%
|
| Sylvester Stallone | 6, 1976-2006 | Rocky Balboa | 92%
|
| Alan Rickman | 8, 2001-2011 | Severus Snape | 76%
|
| Robert Pattinson | 5, 2008-2012 | Edward Cullen | 69%
|
| Patrick Stewart | 6, 2000-2014 | Charles Xavier | 62%
|
| Christopher Lee | 10, 1958-1976 | Dracula | 62%
|
| Peter Sellers | 3, 1963-1976 | Jacques Clouseau | 53%
|
| Robert Englund | 7, 1984-2003 | Freddy Krueger | 49%
|
| Danny Trejo | 7, 2001-2013 | Machete Cortez | 46%
|
| Kenny Baker | 7, 1977-2015 | R2-D2 | 44%
|
| Kevin Smith | 6, 1994-2006 | Silent Bob | 41%
|
| Johnny Weissmuller | 12, 1932-1948 | Tarzan | 41%
|
| Basil Rathbone | 15, 1939-1946 | Sherlock Holmes | 39%
|
| Desmond Llewelyn | 17, 1963-1999 | Q | 35%
|
| James Doohan | 8, 1979-1994 | Montgomery Scott | 30%
|
| Nichelle Nichols | 6, 1979-1991 | Nyota Uhura | 28%
|
| Jim Varney | 11, 1987-1998 | Ernest P. Worrell | 26%
|
| Tobin Bell | 7, 2004-2010 | Jigsaw | 26%
|
| Raymond Burr | 26, 1985-1993 | Perry Mason | 23%
|
| William Boyd | 69, 1935-1953 | Hopalong Cassidy | 6%
|