| Spoiler | Movie | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Reality is an elaborate computer simulation | The Matrix | 78%
|
| It all might be a dream within a dream | Inception | 76%
|
| The ghost-masked killer is not one person, but two | Scream | 67%
|
| Barbossa and his crew are actually undead | Pirates of the Caribbean | 64%
|
| The marshal investigating an asylum is one of the patients | Shutter Island | 53%
|
| The killer robot is the good guy now | T2: Judgment Day | 52%
|
| The magician's silent aide is his twin brother | The Prestige | 46%
|
| Man tasked with hunting androids is himself an android | Blade Runner | 45%
|
| SHIELD is actually Hydra | Captain America: The Winter Soldier | 45%
|
| Mr. Glass is a supervillain | Unbreakable | 41%
|
| The corpse lying on the ground is the sadistic killer | Saw | 39%
|
| The detective already killed John G, but he forgot | Memento | 38%
|
| Cheating husband suspected of murder was framed by the alleged victim | Gone Girl | 33%
|
| The scary aliens terrorizing a town are easily dispatched with water | Signs | 28%
|
| V'Ger is really the Voyager 6 | Star Trek: The Motion Picture | 27%
|
| Photosensitive family tormented by ghosts are themselves ghosts | The Others | 24%
|
| A wave of mass suicides have been caused by disgruntled plants | The Happening | 21%
|
| The protagonist's precious cargo is the last copy of the King James Bible | The Book of Eli | 20%
|
| IRA member discovers he's dating a transvestite | The Crying Game | 18%
|
| Altar boy is faking split personalities to avoid a murder conviction | Primal Fear | 17%
|