| Character | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Satan | Trey Parker | 93%
|
| Jesus | Matt Stone | 91%
|
| Chef | Isaac Hayes | 73%
|
| Sparky | George Clooney | 45%
|
| Miss Stevens | Jennifer Aniston | 22%
|
| Kitty | Jay Leno | 14%
|
| Narrator on the episode "Pip" | Malcolm McDowell | 12%
|
| Ms. Ellen | Natasha Henstridge | 8%
|
| Carlos Ramirez | Cheech Marin | 7%
|
| Chief Running Pinto | Tommy Chong | 7%
|
| Monster from City on the Edge of Forever | Henry Winkler | 4%
|
| Scuzzlebutt's leg from the same episode | Brent Musburger | 3%
|
| Benjamin Franklin | Norman Lear | 3%
|
| Batdad | Diedrich Bader | 2%
|
| Loogie | Richard Belzer | 2%
|