| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| To win the World Series five years in a row | New York Yankees | 91%
|
| In Canada | Toronto Blue Jays | 91%
|
| Formerly in Canada | Washington Nationals | 91%
|
| Founded in the National League, but is now in the American League | Houston Astros | 82%
|
| That has never appeared in the World Series | Seattle Mariners | 82%
|
| To go over one hundred years between World Series titles | Chicago Cubs | 73%
|
| That has never won the World Series, nor its division | Colorado Rockies | 73%
|
| Whose team name is the state bird of its home state | Baltimore Orioles | 64%
|
| That has lost the World Series on purpose | Chicago White Sox | 64%
|
| To win the World Series within its first four seasons as an expansion franchise | Arizona Diamondbacks | 55%
|
| Without a geographic identifier in their name | Athletics | 55%
|
| To win the World Series in seasons exactly 100 years apart | Boston Red Sox | 55%
|
| To never lose 100+ games in any season | Los Angeles Angels | 55%
|
| To win the World Series (twice) despite never winning their division | Miami Marlins | 55%
|
| Founded in the American League, but is now in the National League | Milwaukee Brewers | 55%
|
| Whose current home field is a domed stadium | Tampa Bay Rays | 55%
|
| That has won the World Series representing three different cities | Atlanta Braves | 45%
|
| To throw two consecutive no-hitters from the same pitcher | Cincinnati Reds | 45%
|
| To win their division after being 15.5 games behind | Cleveland Guardians | 45%
|
| To lose a no-hit bid in the ninth inning twice in a three-game span | Los Angeles Dodgers | 45%
|
| To lose over ten thousand games representing the same city | Philadelphia Phillies | 45%
|
| To pitch 12+ strikeouts while giving up 0 earned runs in a game, and lose | Detroit Tigers | 36%
|
| To pull off two triple plays in a single game | Minnesota Twins | 36%
|
| With a color scheme inspired by two previous teams that played in the city | New York Mets | 36%
|
| That shares its colors with all other major sports teams in their city | Pittsburgh Pirates | 36%
|
| To go undefeated 26 games in a row (including ties) | San Francisco Giants | 36%
|
| That did not pitch a no-hitter until the 2020s | San Diego Padres | 27%
|
| That has retired the number 85 | St. Louis Cardinals | 27%
|
| That does not host a Pride Night game during Pride Month | Texas Rangers | 27%
|
| Named in honor of a livestock show | Kansas City Royals | 18%
|