| # | Team | WAR | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 69.6 | Mookie Betts | 97%
|
| 13 | New York Yankees | 52.2 | Aaron Judge | 95%
|
| 1 | Los Angeles Angels | 86.2 | Mike Trout | 95%
|
| 14 | Philadelphia Phillies | 51.1 | Bryce Harper | 92%
|
| 3 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 79.4 | Clayton Kershaw | 92%
|
| 7 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 60.7 | Freddie Freeman | 92%
|
| 8 | San Diego Padres | 57.8 | Manny Machado | 92%
|
| 21 | Los Angeles Dodgers | 43.8 | Shohei Ohtani | 92%
|
| 15 | New York Mets | 49.6 | Francisco Lindor | 89%
|
| 2 | San Francisco Giants | 80.5 | Justin Verlander | 89%
|
| 4 | Toronto Blue Jays | 75.4 | Max Scherzer | 89%
|
| 22 | New York Yankees | 43.3 | Gerrit Cole | 86%
|
| 16 | Pittsburgh Pirates | 49.3 | Andrew McCutchen | 84%
|
| 11 | Houston Astros | 52.8 | Jose Altuve | 84%
|
| 6 | New York Yankees | 62.8 | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| 19 | New York Yankees | 44.7 | Giancarlo Stanton | 81%
|
| 12 | Cleveland Guardians | 52.4 | Jose Ramirez | 81%
|
| 9 | St. Louis Cardinals | 56.7 | Nolan Arenado | 81%
|
| 23 | Milwaukee Brewers | 41.9 | Christian Yelich | 73%
|
| 18 | Texas Rangers | 45.2 | Jacob deGrom | 73%
|
| 10 | Atlanta Braves | 53.4 | Chris Sale | 68%
|
| 20 | Minnesota Twins | 44.4 | Carlos Correa | 62%
|
| 17 | Texas Rangers | 45.8 | Marcus Semien | 59%
|
| 25 | San Diego Padres | 40.8 | Xander Bogaerts | 38%
|
| 24 | Free Agent | 41.8 | Jason Heyward | 8%
|