| Competing Teams | Rivalry Trophy | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Minnesota, Wisconsin | Paul Bunyan's Axe | 67%
|
| Iowa, Iowa State | Cy-Hawk Trophy | 33%
|
| Iowa, Minnesota | Floyd of Rosedale | 33%
|
| Arkansas, Louisiana State | Golden Boot | 33%
|
| Oklahoma, Texas | Golden Hat | 33%
|
| Georgia, Georgia Tech | Kansas, Kansas State | Kentucky, Louisville | Governor's Cup | 33%
|
| Southern Methodist, Texas Christian | Iron Skillet | 33%
|
| Michigan, Minnesota | Little Brown Jug | 33%
|
| Michigan, Michigan State | Paul Bunyan Trophy | 33%
|
| Arizona, Arizona State | Territorial Cup | 33%
|
| Louisiana State, Tulane | Tiger Rag | 33%
|
| California - Los Angeles, Southern California | Duke, North Carolina | Missouri, Nebraska | Pacific, San Jose State | Victory Bell | 33%
|
| Brigham Young, Utah, Utah State | Beehive Boot | 22%
|
| Texas, Texas Tech | Chancellor's Spurs | 22%
|
| Air Force, Army, Navy | Commander-in-Chief's Trophy | 22%
|
| Florida, Florida State, Miami | Florida Cup | 22%
|
| Nevada, Nevada - Las Vegas | Fremont Cannon | 22%
|
| Notre Dame, Southern California | Jeweled Shillelagh | 22%
|
| Illinois, Northwestern | Land of Lincoln Trophy | 22%
|
| Notre Dame, Stanford | Legends Trophy | 22%
|
| Michigan State, Notre Dame | Megaphone Trophy | 22%
|
| Indiana, Purdue | Old Oaken Bucket | 22%
|
| Florida, Miami | Seminole War Canoe | 22%
|
| Iowa State, Missouri | Telephone Trophy | 22%
|
| Clemson, North Carolina State | Textile Bowl | 22%
|
| California, Stanford | The Axe | 22%
|
| Cincinnati, Louisville | The Keg of Nails | 22%
|
| Akron, Kent State | Wagon Wheel | 22%
|
| Minnesota, Nebraska | $5 Bits of Broken Chair Trophy | 11%
|
| Bowling Green, Kent State | Anniversary Award | 11%
|
| Washington, Washington State | Apple Cup Trophy | 11%
|
| Arkansas, Missouri | Battle Line Trophy | 11%
|
| Bowling Green, Toledo | Battle of I-75 Trophy | 11%
|
| Delaware, Villanova | Battle of the Blue Trophy | 11%
|
| Houston, Rice | Bayou Bucket | 11%
|
| Oklahoma, Oklahoma State | Bedlam Bell | 11%
|
| Syracuse, West Virginia | Ben Schwartzwalder Trophy | 11%
|
| Virginia Tech, West Virginia | Black Diamond Trophy | 11%
|
| Baylor, Texas Christian | Bluebonnet Shield | 11%
|
| Ball State, Indiana State | Blue Key Victory Bell | 11%
|
| Utah State, Wyoming | Bridger Rifle | 11%
|
| Colorado State, Wyoming | Bronze Boot | 11%
|
| Ball State, Northern Illinois | Bronze Stalk Trophy | 11%
|
| Louisiana, McNeese | Cajun Crown | 11%
|
| Colorado, Colorado State | Centennial Cup | 11%
|
| Virginia, Virginia Tech | Commonwealth Cup | 11%
|
| Maryland, Navy | Crab Bowl Trophy | 11%
|
| Louisiana, Southeastern Louisiana | Cypress Mug | 11%
|
| Hawaii, San Jose State | Dick Tomey Legacy Trophy | 11%
|
| Florida Atlantic, Florida International | Don Shula Award | 11%
|
| Delaware, Delaware State | First State Cup | 11%
|
| Alabama, Auburn | Foy-ODK Sportsmanship Trophy | 11%
|
| Nebraska, Wisconsin | Freedom Trophy | 11%
|
| Navy, Southern Methodist | Gansz Trophy | 11%
|
| Michigan, Northwestern | George Jewitt Trophy | 11%
|
| Georgia Tech, Vanderbilt | Gold Cowbell | 11%
|
| Mississippi, Mississippi State | Golden Egg Trophy | 11%
|
| California State - Fresno, Hawaii | Golden Screwdriver | 11%
|
| Minnesota, Pennsylvania State | Governor's Victory Bell | 11%
|
| Iowa, Wisconsin | Heartland Trophy | 11%
|
| Iowa, Nebraska | Heroes Trophy | 11%
|
| Illinois, Ohio State | Illibuck Trophy | 11%
|
| Kansas, Missouri | Indian War Drum | 11%
|
| Boston College, Notre Dame | Ireland Trophy | 11%
|
| Florida State, Virginia | Jefferson-Eppes Trophy | 11%
|
| Air Force, Hawaii | Kuter Trophy | 11%
|
| Michigan State, Pennsylvania State | Land Grant Trophy | 11%
|
| Louisiana State, Mississippi | Magnolia Bowl Trophy | 11%
|
| Florida, Florida State | Makala Trophy | 11%
|
| Rice, Southern Methodist | Temple, Villanova | Mayor's Cup | 11%
|
| Central Michigan, Eastern Michigan, Western Michigan | Michigan MAC Trophy | 11%
|
| Boise State, California State - Fresno | Milk Can | 11%
|
| California State - Fresno, San Diego State | Oil Can | 11%
|
| Florida, Georgia | Okefenokee Oar | 11%
|
| Indiana, Michigan State | Old Brass Spittoon | 11%
|
| Pennsylvania State, Pittsburgh, West Virginia | Old Ironsides | 11%
|
| Boston College, Clemson | O'Rourke-McFadden Trophy | 11%
|
| Texas State, Nicholls | Paddle Trophy | 11%
|
| Hawaii, Wyoming | Paniolo Trophy | 11%
|
| Oregon, Oregon State | Platypus Trophy | 11%
|
| Illinois, Purdue | Purdue Cannon | 11%
|
| Air Force, Colorado State | Ram-Falcon Trophy | 11%
|
| Western Kentucky, Murray State | Red Belt | 11%
|
| Navy, Notre Dame | Rip Miller Trophy | 11%
|
| James Madison, Old Dominion | Royal Rivalry Trophy | 11%
|
| Louisiana, Lamar | Sabine Shoe | 11%
|
| Boston College, Boston University, Holy Cross | Sacred Cod Trophy | 11%
|
| Texas Christian, Texas Tech | Saddle Trophy | 11%
|
| Louisville, Miami | Schnellenberger Trophy | 11%
|
| Army, Navy | Secretary's Trophy | 11%
|
| Notre Dame, Purdue | Shillelagh Trophy | 11%
|
| New Mexico State, Texas - El Paso | Silver Spade | 11%
|
| Arkansas, Texas A&M | Southwest Classic Trophy | 11%
|
| Akron, Youngstown State | Steel Tire | 11%
|
| Marshall, Ohio | Southern Mississippi, Tulane | The Bell | 11%
|
| South Alabama, Troy | The Belt | 11%
|
| Alabama - Birmingham, Memphis | The Bones | 11%
|
| Indiana, Kentucky | The Bourbon Barrel | 11%
|
| Oregon, Saint Mary's | The Governors' Perpetual Trophy | 11%
|
| Brigham Young, Utah State | The Old Wagon Wheel | 11%
|
| Middle Tennessee, Troy | The Palladium Trophy | 11%
|
| Missouri, Oklahoma | Tiger-Sooner Peace Pipe | 11%
|
| California State - Fresno, San Jose State | Valley Trophy | 11%
|
| East Carolina, North Carolina State | Victory Barrel | 11%
|
| Central Michigan, Western Michigan | Victory Cannon | 11%
|
| Central Florida, South Florida | War on I-4 Trophy | 11%
|
| Louisiana, Louisiana - Monroe | Wooden Boot | 11%
|