| Clue | Movie | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "You're killin' me, Smalls" | The Sandlot | 85%
|
| Farmer plows over his corn to build a baseball field | Field of Dreams | 83%
|
| Girls play pro baseball during WWII | A League of Their Own | 78%
|
| Oakland A's use statistical analysis to put together an inexpensive winning team | Moneyball | 78%
|
| Middle aged high school science teacher becomes a Major League relief pitcher | The Rookie | 78%
|
| 2013 film telling the story of Jackie Robinson and his battle with racism | 42 | 77%
|
| New owner of the Indians wants to lose on purpose so the team is relocated | Major League | 74%
|
| Alcoholic little league coach turns around a team of misfits | The Bad News Bears | 68%
|
| Foster child prays to God to help his favorite team win and He sends winged help | Angels in the Outfield | 63%
|
| 12 year old throws incredible fastballs for the Cubs | Rookie of the Year | 61%
|
| Veteran minor league catcher mentors rookie pitcher for life in the big leagues | Bull Durham | 55%
|
| Player with great God-given ability hits a pennant winning home run into the lights | The Natural | 53%
|
| Due to a stat error, a retired player only has 2,997 hits and makes a comeback | Mr. 3000 | 50%
|
| Mickey Mantle and Roger Maris attempt to break Babe Ruth's home run record | 61* | 42%
|
| Dramatization of the 1919 Chicago "Black Sox" scandal | Eight Men Out | 40%
|
| 12 year old becomes owner and manager of the Minnesota Twins | Little Big League | 38%
|
| Romantic comedy set during the 2004 Red Sox World Series win | Fever Pitch | 36%
|
| Retiring pitcher reminisces about his life during his last start and throws a perfect game | For Love of the Game | 32%
|
| Film chronicling the life and career of Lou Gehrig | Pride of the Yankees | 25%
|
| Catcher is terminally ill with Hodgkin's disease and pitcher stays by his side | Bang the Drum Slowly | 16%
|