| Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Magical dog with Stretchy Powers | Jake | 100%
|
| The "Mathematical" Human Adventurer | Finn | 99%
|
| Kidnaps princesses | Ice King | 94%
|
| "Who wants to play video games?" | BMO | 92%
|
| _________ the Vampire Queen | Marceline | 91%
|
| Her best friend is a rainicorn, rides a Royal Swan | Princess Bubblegum | 86%
|
| Penguin, wanted the above's soul | Gunter/Gunther | 83%
|
| PB's servant, and a friend of Death | Peppermint Butler | 81%
|
| Girlfriend of the above | Lady Rainicorn | 80%
|
| The human boy's female counterpart | Fionna | 79%
|
| Bakes apple pies | Tree Trunks | 79%
|
| Princess with a star on her forehead | LSP | 78%
|
| The stretchy dog's female counterpart | Cake | 77%
|
| The above, but before the Mushroom War | Simon Petrikov | 66%
|
| Sealed away in amber, possessed a snail | The Lich | 60%
|
| Dog-Rainicorn Puppy #5 | Jake Jr. | 53%
|
| Hero who slayed an Evil Ocean | Billy | 51%
|
| Dog-Rainicorn Puppy #2 | T.V. | 47%
|
| Ruler of the Nightosphere | Hunson Abadeer | 46%
|
| Pet of the above; he's a candy-corn rat | Science | 44%
|
| Original owner of the demon's blood sword | Joshua | 40%
|
| Dog-Rainicorn Puppy #3 | Viola | 32%
|
| Dog-Rainicorn Puppy #4 | Kim Kil Whan | 31%
|
| Dog-Rainicorn Puppy #1 | Charlie | 30%
|