This is a pretty good, comprehensive list overall, but it flabbergasts me that they chose the Leonard Cohen version of "Hallelujah" over the Jeff Buckley one. Buckley's version is objectively better. Also, it's not as though they have an aversion to covers, otherwise they wouldn't put down Whitney Houston for "I Will Always Love You." Anyways, that's just my gripe with the list; great quiz though!
A very close call, but when I want to listen to Hallelujah I play the Cohen version. Also I think a nod is given to the original when the original performer also wrote the song. I haven't looked through the list enough to prove that theory, though.
Dylan liked Hendrix's version far more than his own having gone on record saying "It was Jimi's song, I just wrote it." In the liner notes of his album Biograph, he says "I liked Jimi Hendrix's record of this {All Along the Watchtower} and ever since he died I've been doing it that way... Strange how when I sing it, I always feel it's a tribute to him in some kind of way."
This has no bearing on the subjective choice with respect to which version is better, just an interesting factoid.
When I first opened this quiz I got really confused. What do you mean "guess the artist?" Wouldn't all of the answers be "The Rolling Stones??" Oh, THAT Rolling Stone.
It wasn't until this comment that I realised this list wasn't by the band the Rolling Stones... Thought Gasolina was a very leftfield choice from Jagger...
Might as well have "F The Police" at number one. 50 years from now people are going to look really stupid trying desperately to stay on the "right" side of history.
Hmm, I like Swift, but that song is basically the most overused chord sequence in pop on loop. It's become a meme it's so unoriginal. (Funny that the Rolling Stone write up says "She ad-libbed lyrics over chords she had written..."). It's a lot blander than much of her other work imo.
Nice quiz. I scored 81/100, but I honestly have not heard of most of the songs that I missed. Or I guessed other versions, like with "Gloria". I tried Them, Van Morrison, Laura Branigan, no good. Well, I still had fun, thanks!
More like upset that they encompass the top spots of a list where The Beatles, Rolling Stones, Johnny Cash ect. are barely mentioned. The top songs are nowhere in the same solar system as being good as anything those bands mentioned above have EVER produced, yet this "magazine" is reaching to put them in spots they clearly don't deserve to be in to look "edgy" and for attention. If you're okay being fed bullshit all the time, than go ahead and think it's okay. Anyone with a functioning brain or set of properly working eyes can see right through the BS.
yet another pretentious loser who thinks pink floyd is objectively better than pop music, music is subjective at the end of the day and if you ask the average person what they think the answers will vary a lot, Royals and Dancing on my own are very popular well crafted songs while pink floyd are much older and less likely to appear on a modern list of good music
I really enjoy both Royals and Dancing On My Own. I don't particularly like classic rock, but it seems a very tough sell to me to suggest that Comfortably Dumb is not better than Royals or Dancing On My Own. (For that matter, I think it's better than a whole lot of songs on this list, including a lot of the classic rock selections.)
Something to consider: a song's "greatness" is more than how much you like it. "Gasolina," for example, is just a club song...except it isn't. I don't know if it was the first song to use that now-ubiquitous reggaeton beat, but it was definitely the first one I (and I suspect most people) ever heard. It launched that whole genre, which is now huge, into the mainstream consciousness. That matters a lot more than the 10,000th classic rock that, yes, has lots of cool riffs and vocals, but also sounds like a lot of what came before it.
I'll add, as a white guy in Chicago, that one of the 2025 Cubs' pitchers uses "Gasolina" as his entrance music, and I swear, whenever the song starts, you can see every single Hispanic person in the ballpark leap to their feet and turn the ballpark into the Tropicana for two minutes. It's insane how popular that song still is in that community. It absolutely lights a fire in people (forgive the pun) 22 years later. So yes, sorry, it's worthy.
This has no bearing on the subjective choice with respect to which version is better, just an interesting factoid.
^ yours checks out too
I'll add, as a white guy in Chicago, that one of the 2025 Cubs' pitchers uses "Gasolina" as his entrance music, and I swear, whenever the song starts, you can see every single Hispanic person in the ballpark leap to their feet and turn the ballpark into the Tropicana for two minutes. It's insane how popular that song still is in that community. It absolutely lights a fire in people (forgive the pun) 22 years later. So yes, sorry, it's worthy.