| Team | Assumed Role | Captain | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Washington Capitals | 2009 | Alexander Ovechkin | 100%
|
| Pittsburgh Penguins | 2007 | Sidney Crosby | 100%
|
| Tampa Bay Lightning | 2013 | Steven Stamkos | 100%
|
| Florida Panthers | 2018 | Aleksander Barkov | 96%
|
| Edmonton Oilers | 2016 | Connor McDavid | 96%
|
| Chicago Blackhawks | 2008 | Jonathon Toews | 96%
|
| Boston Bruins | 2006 | Zdeno Chara | 96%
|
| Winnipeg Jets | 2016 | Blake Wheeler | 92%
|
| Colorado Avalanche | 2012 | Gabe Landeskog | 92%
|
| Anaheim Ducks | 2010 | Ryan Getzlaf | 92%
|
| LA Kings | 2016 | Anze Kopitar | 88%
|
| Buffalo Sabres | 2018 | Jack Eichel | 88%
|
| Philadelphia Flyers | 2012 | Claude Giroux | 84%
|
| Dallas Stars | 2013 | Jamie Benn | 84%
|
| Nashville Predators | 2017 | Roman Josi | 84%
|
| St Louis Blues | 2016 | Alex Pietrangelo | 80%
|
| Calgary Flames | 2013 | Mike Giordano | 80%
|
| San Jose Sharks | 2015 | Joe Pavelski | 76%
|
| Montreal Canadiens | 2018 | Shea Weber | 76%
|
| Toronto Maple Leafs | Vacant | Marleau / Rielly / Tavares | 72%
|
| Arizona Coyotes | 2018 | Oliver Ekman-Larsson | 68%
|
| New York Rangers | Vacant | Fast / Kreider / Staal / Zibanejad | 64%
|
| Minnesota Wild | 2009 | Mikko Koivu | 64%
|
| Detroit Red Wings | Vacant | Abdelkader / Kronwall / Larkin / Nielsen | 60%
|
| New York Islanders | 2018 | Anders Lee | 60%
|
| New Jersey Devils | 2015 | Andy Greene | 56%
|
| Carolina Hurricanes | 2018 | Justin Williams | 56%
|
| Columbus Blue Jackets | 2015 | Nick Foligno | 56%
|
| Vancouver Canucks | Vacant | Edler / Horvat / Sutter / Tanev | 52%
|
| Vegas Golden Knights | Vacant | Bellemare / Engelland / Smith | 36%
|
| Ottowa Senators | Vacant | Borowiecki / Smith | 32%
|