| Rank | Position | Years Active | Stats | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | C | 1991-1997, 2000-2004 | 698 GP - 250 G - 691 PTS | Mark Messier | 92%
|
| 7 | G | 2005- | 459-310-96 - 2.43 GAA - .918 SP% | Henrik Lundqvist | 86%
|
| 2 | D | 1987-2004 | 1129 GP - 240 G - 981 PTS | Brian Leetch | 80%
|
| 6 | RW | 1961-1978 | 1065 GP - 406 G - 1021 PTS | Rod Gilbert | 55%
|
| 8 | C | 1960-1975 | 862 GP - 336 G - 817 PTS | Jean Ratelle | 36%
|
| 5 | RW | 1952-1964 | 719 GP - 272 G - 729 PTS | Andy Bathgate | 27%
|
| 1 | RW | 1926-1937 | 474 GP - 229 G - 367 PTS | Bill Cook | 18%
|
| 4 | C | 1926-1944 | 533 GP - 152 G - 413 PTS | Frank Boucher | 7%
|
| 9 | D | 1926-1937 | 405 GP - 38 G - 86 PTS | Ching Johnson | 4%
|
| 10 | G | 1945-1953 | 123-180-72 - 2.99 GAA - n/a SP% | Chuck Rayner | 2%
|