| Movie | Winner | Year | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| King Richard | Will Smith | 2022 | 100%
|
| Training Day | Denzel Washington | 2002 | 95%
|
| Glory | Denzel Washington | 1990 | 95%
|
| Sinners | Michael B. Jordan | 2026 | 84%
|
| Monster's Ball | Halle Berry | 2002 | 79%
|
| Ray | Jamie Foxx | 2005 | 74%
|
| Million Dollar Baby | Morgan Freeman | 2005 | 68%
|
| Lilies of the Field | Sidney Poitier | 1964 | 68%
|
| Ghost | Whoopi Goldberg | 1991 | 68%
|
| The Last King of Scotland | Forest Whitaker | 2007 | 63%
|
| Green Book | Mahershala Ali | 2019 | 58%
|
| Moonlight | Mahershala Ali | 2017 | 58%
|
| Fences | Viola Davis | 2017 | 58%
|
| Jerry Maguire | Cuba Gooding Jr. | 1997 | 47%
|
| Dreamgirls | Jennifer Hudson | 2007 | 47%
|
| An Officer and a Gentlemen | Louis Gossett Jr. | 1983 | 47%
|
| The Help | Octavia Spencer | 2012 | 47%
|
| Judas and the Black Messiah | Daniel Kaluuya | 2021 | 42%
|
| Gone with the Wind | Hattie McDaniel | 1940 | 42%
|
| 12 Years a Slave | Lupita Nyong'o | 2014 | 42%
|
| Precious | Mo'Nique | 2010 | 37%
|
| Emilia Perez | Zoe Saldana | 2025 | 37%
|
| West Side Story | Ariana DeBose | 2022 | 26%
|
| If Beale Street Could Talk | Regina King | 2019 | 26%
|
| The Holdovers | Da'Vine Joy Randolph | 2024 | 21%
|