| SB | Team | Pos. | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IX | Steelers | FB | Franco Harris | 100%
|
| LIV | Chiefs | QB | Patrick Mahomes | 100%
|
| XL | Steelers | QB | Ben Roethlisberger | 75%
|
| LIX | Eagles | QB | Jalen Hurts | 75%
|
| LVII | Eagles | QB | Jalen Hurts | 75%
|
| XXIX | 49ers | WR | Jerry Rice | 75%
|
| XXIV | 49ers | WR | Jerry Rice | 75%
|
| XVI | 49ers | QB | Joe Montana | 75%
|
| XLVIII | Seahawks | RB | Marshawn Lynch | 75%
|
| LV | Buccaneers | TE | Rob Gronkowski | 75%
|
| XII | Cowboys | RB | Tony Dorsett | 75%
|
| XLVII | Ravens | WR | Anquan Boldin | 50%
|
| XXXII | Packers | WR | Antonio Freeman | 50%
|
| XV | Raiders | WR | Cliff Branch | 50%
|
| XXXVIII | Patriots | WR | Deion Branch | 50%
|
| XLI | Bears | KR | Devin Hester | 50%
|
| LI | Falcons | RB | Devonta Freeman | 50%
|
| X | Cowboys | WR | Drew Pearson | 50%
|
| XXVI | Redskins | RB | Earnest Byner | 50%
|
| XXX | Cowboys | TE | Jay Novacek | 50%
|
| XIII | Steelers | WR | John Stallworth | 50%
|
| XLV | Packers | WR | Jordy Nelson | 50%
|
| VIII | Dolphins | FB | Larry Csonka | 50%
|
| I | Packers | WR | Max McGee | 50%
|
| XXXVII | Buccaneers | FB | Mike Alstott | 50%
|
| LVI | Rams | WR | Odell Beckham, Jr. | 50%
|
| XXIII | Bengals | KR | Stanford Jennings | 50%
|
| XXVIII | Bills | RB | Thurman Thomas | 50%
|
| XXVII | Bills | RB | Thurman Thomas | 50%
|
| XXXIV | Rams | WR | Torry Holt | 50%
|
| XXXVI | Patriots | CB | Ty Law | 50%
|
| XLVI | Giants | WR | Victor Cruz | 50%
|
| LII | Eagles | WR | Alshon Jeffery | 25%
|
| XXXI | Packers | WR | Andre Rison | 25%
|
| II | Packers | WR | Boyd Dowler | 25%
|
| XXXV | Ravens | WR | Brandon Stokley | 25%
|
| XI | Raiders | TE | Dave Casper | 25%
|
| XVII | Dolphins | WR | Jimmy Cefalo | 25%
|
| V | Colts | TE | John Mackey | 25%
|
| VI | Cowboys | WR | Lance Alworth | 25%
|
| 50 | Broncos | DT | Malik Jackson | 25%
|
| III | Jets | RB | Matt Snell | 25%
|
| XX | Bears | FB | Matt Suhey | 25%
|
| IV | Chiefs | RB | Mike Garrett | 25%
|
| LIII | Patriots | RB | Sony Michel | 25%
|
| XLIX | Patriots | WR | Brandon LaFell | 0%
|
| XIX | 49ers | RB | Carl Monroe | 0%
|
| LVIII | 49ers | RB | Christian McCaffery | 0%
|
| XIV | Rams | RB | Cullen Bryant | 0%
|
| XVIII | Raiders | RB | Derrick Jensen | 0%
|
| XXV | Bills | RB | Don Smith | 0%
|
| XLIII | Steelers | RB | Gary Russell | 0%
|
| XXXIII | Broncos | FB | Howard Griffith | 0%
|
| VII | Dolphins | WR | Howard Twilley | 0%
|
| XLII | Patriots | RB | Laurence Maroney | 0%
|
| XXXIX | Eagles | TE | L.J. Smith | 0%
|
| XLIV | Colts | WR | Pierre Garcon | 0%
|
| XXII | Broncos | WR | Ricky Nattiel | 0%
|
| XXI | Giants | TE | Zeke Mowatt | 0%
|