| Rank | Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Clown | The Joker | 100%
|
| #2 | Feline | Catwoman | 99%
|
| #8 | Puzzles | Riddler | 98%
|
| #5 | Cold | Mr. Freeze | 97%
|
| #10 | Fear | Scarecrow | 96%
|
| #3 | Split | Two-Face | 96%
|
| #6 | Bird | Penguin | 95%
|
| #9 | Plants | Poison Ivy | 95%
|
| #7 | Jester | Harley Quinn | 91%
|
| #16 | Bat | Man-Bat | 90%
|
| #12 | Venom | Bane | 87%
|
| #13 | Sewer | Killer Croc | 87%
|
| #4 | Shadows | Ra's al Ghul | 82%
|
| #19 | Shapeshift | Clayface | 78%
|
| #20 | Bandages | Hush | 69%
|
| #14 | Psychiatrist | Hugo Strange | 63%
|
| #23 | Swine | Professor Pyg | 52%
|
| #21 | Puppet | Ventriloquist | 52%
|
| #11 | Mother | Talia Al Ghul | 51%
|
| #15 | Sombrero | Mad Hatter | 45%
|
| #17 | Mafia | Carmine Falcone | 44%
|
| #25 | Group | The Court of Owls | 35%
|
| #22 | Martial Arts | Lady Shiva | 25%
|
| #24 | Notch | Mr. Zsasz | 25%
|
| #18 | Devil | Doctor Hurt | 2%
|